WikiLean ยท Articles Articles Brain Contribute About

Preliminary: these links have not yet had an independent audit.

Tangent

89 passages21 formalized17 partial51 not formalized

Statement only

More ways to filter
Library
About this page

This page

  • Wikipedia revision 1348491347, pinned: the text here is that revision, not today's article.
  • WikiProject Mathematics: C-class, High importance
  • Annotated article on WikiLean.
  • 89 passages checked, 70 Lean locations (and 33 related declarations).

Central statements: 42 of the 89 passages state the article's subject or a named result or definition; the other 47 are supporting (examples, setup). Of these 42: 11 formalized, 11 partial, 20 not formalized.

What the colours mean

  • Formalized a Lean declaration states it, proved, or a Lean definition defines it
  • Statement only Lean states it, but the proof is not finished
  • Partial Lean states part of it, or a more general or special form
  • Not formalized searched every library and not found

Libraries searched

Searched 48 Lean libraries, pinned 2026-10-17, 3 left out (library set u1).

How these links were made

  • Accuracy, from an audit of a sample of 224 items (blind, not independent): Strong links (exact, close or broad match) on supporting passages that have exactly the right relation: 92% (95% interval 49โ€“99%), from 36 drawn of 1029, weighted by relation and library, an effective sample of 5.1; Links in a counting relation (exact, close, broad, narrow match or part) on supporting passages that have exactly the right relation: 73% (95% interval 40โ€“92%), from 48 drawn of 1740, weighted by relation and library, an effective sample of 8.1; Central and subject passages whose formalization status is right: 86% (95% interval 73โ€“94%), from 44 drawn of 1905, weighted by recorded status, an effective sample of 42; 'Not formalized' on supporting passages that is right (no declaration in the 48 libraries states it): 60% (95% interval 25โ€“87%), from 12 drawn of 1236, weighted by article, an effective sample of 6.1.
  • Audit run tierA-batch1-audit, run by jack, 2 Nov 2026, 21:10 โ€“ 3 Nov 2026, 02:10 UTC: judged by Claude Opus 5.5 (claude-opus-5-5).
  • Record set tierA-b1b (cf-locate-recordset/2, statuses by status rule 3), exported 1 Nov 2026 by formal-companion at commit d85385a.
  • Seal sha256 23710337d053e8212378a9e580805628bcdfda61a6fc431e65f24a4a16c9e602.
  • Inventory run inv-tierA-b1r, run by jack, 30 Oct 2026, 07:23โ€“20:00 UTC: worker Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5), reviewer Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5). It listed the formal passages, each with its kind and prominence, that the locate run then searched.
  • Locate run loc-tierA-b1b, run by jack, 31 Oct 2026, 04:59 โ€“ 1 Nov 2026, 03:06 UTC: worker Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5), reviewer Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5).
  • Challenge run chal-tierA-b1, run by jack, 1 Nov 2026, 03:19โ€“14:25 UTC: worker Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5), reviewer Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5). In this article it re-checked every Lean location and absence on a central or subject passage (38 locations and 20 absences); on supporting passages, a seeded sample (seed 0; drawn at 0.5 for strong matches, 0.2 for weaker links and 0.25 for absences): 24 of 32 locations and 8 of 28 absences. In all, 62 of 70 Lean locations (89%) and 28 of 48 absences (58%) were re-checked.
  • Passage text: 89 of 89 passages shown in full, each the slice of the pinned revision's text that its record's span sha256 hashes, checked when the store was built.
  • Lean code: each declaration's type, from the declaration corpus of universe u1 (built 18 Oct 2026, sha256 a364fd6aede5), at the commit its card links.

How the text is shown

Each passage is shown in full, as revision 1348491347 states it (checked against its record's span hash when the store was built). Where a passage is only part of a sentence, it is highlighted and the rest of the sentence is shown in grey around it, from the same copy of the revision; a list item also shows the sentence that introduces it. Formulas are drawn from their TeX; hover one to see it.

Each card's Lean code is its declaration's type as Lean prints it, from the declaration corpus of library set u1 at the card's commit, laid out as a header: binders before the colon, then the hypotheses as arrows (the corpus keeps no hypothesis names) and the conclusion, in Mathlib's notation (๐“, ฯ€, R[X], Type*). It is not the source text; Source opens that.

Passages

What โ€œexact matchโ€, โ€œmore generalโ€ and the other labels mean
  1. Definition ยท Subject of the article

    Partial

    Partial: Mathlib states a special case (a definition).

    In geometry, the tangent line (or simply tangent) to a plane curve at a given point is, intuitively, the straight line that "just touches" the curve at that point.

    Show in article ยท Read it in context on Wikipedia

    EuclideanGeometry.Sphere.IsTangentAt special case

    structure EuclideanGeometry.Sphere.IsTangentAt {V : Type*} {P : Type*} [NormedAddCommGroup V] [InnerProductSpace โ„ V] [MetricSpace P] [NormedAddTorsor V P] : EuclideanGeometry.Sphere P โ†’ P โ†’ AffineSubspace โ„ P โ†’ Prop

    Mathlib.Geometry.Euclidean.Sphere.Tangent ยท lines 64โ€“67

    Why a special case: Mathlib gives this relation for spheres only, so the plane curve it reaches is the circle, while the passage speaks of any plane curve.

    Details
    • Found by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: candidate 1 for this passage, medium confidence.
    • Re-checked by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC), challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack: it survived.
    • Record set tierA-b1b, exported 1 Nov 2026 by formal-companion d85385a.
    • Lean code: the declaration's type as Lean prints it, laid out as a header (the corpus keeps no hypothesis names), from the declaration corpus of universe u1 at commit 3dfb8e2.
    • Location key 80f0db623143 ยท pair key c03e041d979f.
  2. Definition ยท main statement

    Not formalized
    More precisely, a straight line is tangent to the curve y = f(x) at a point x = c if the line passes through the point (c, f(c)) on the curve and has slope f'(c), where f' is the derivative of f.

    Show in article ยท Read it in context on Wikipedia

    Searched 48 libraries โ€” not found. Which libraries, at which commits (pinned 2026-10-17).

    Details
    • Searched by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: the search receipt lists 4 queries and 3 candidates examined (receipt 944b76af03ba).
    • Re-checked by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC), challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack: upheld.
  3. Definition ยท main statement

    Partial

    Partial: Mathlib states a special case (proved).

    The point where the tangent line and the curve meet or intersect is called the point of tangency.

    Show in article ยท Read it in context on Wikipedia

    EuclideanGeometry.Sphere.IsTangentAt.mem_and_mem_iff_eq special case

    theorem EuclideanGeometry.Sphere.IsTangentAt.mem_and_mem_iff_eq {V : Type*} {P : Type*} [NormedAddCommGroup V] [InnerProductSpace โ„ V] [MetricSpace P] [NormedAddTorsor V P] {s : EuclideanGeometry.Sphere P} {p q : P} {as : AffineSubspace โ„ P} : s.IsTangentAt p as โ†’ (q โˆˆ s โˆง q โˆˆ as โ†” q = p)

    Mathlib.Geometry.Euclidean.Sphere.Tangent ยท lines 106โ€“113

    Why a special case: It is stated for spheres, so the curve it covers is a circle rather than any curve.

    Details
    • Found by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: candidate 1 for this passage, medium confidence.
    • Re-checked by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC), challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack: it survived.
    • Record set tierA-b1b, exported 1 Nov 2026 by formal-companion d85385a.
    • Lean code: the declaration's type as Lean prints it, laid out as a header (the corpus keeps no hypothesis names), from the declaration corpus of universe u1 at commit 3dfb8e2.
    • Location key 34b158f0702e ยท pair key 704c127296a3.

    EuclideanGeometry.Sphere.IsTangentAt.eq_of_mem_of_mem special case

    theorem EuclideanGeometry.Sphere.IsTangentAt.eq_of_mem_of_mem {V : Type*} {P : Type*} [NormedAddCommGroup V] [InnerProductSpace โ„ V] [MetricSpace P] [NormedAddTorsor V P] {s : EuclideanGeometry.Sphere P} {p q : P} {as : AffineSubspace โ„ P} : s.IsTangentAt p as โ†’ q โˆˆ s โ†’ q โˆˆ as โ†’ q = p

    Mathlib.Geometry.Euclidean.Sphere.Tangent ยท lines 115โ€“117

    Why a special case: It gives one direction of the equivalence ranked above, still only for circles.

    Details
    • Found by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: candidate 2 for this passage, medium confidence.
    • Re-checked by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC), challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack: it survived.
    • Record set tierA-b1b, exported 1 Nov 2026 by formal-companion d85385a.
    • Lean code: the declaration's type as Lean prints it, laid out as a header (the corpus keeps no hypothesis names), from the declaration corpus of universe u1 at commit 3dfb8e2.
    • Location key 6aea6db6ffdb ยท pair key 8056a91f092f.
  4. Theorem ยท supporting

    Formalized

    Formalized: Mathlib states a more general result (proved).

    The tangent line is said to be "going in the same direction" as the curve, and is thus the best straight-line approximation to the curve at that point.

    Show in article ยท Read it in context on Wikipedia

    hasDerivAt_iff_isLittleO more general

    theorem hasDerivAt_iff_isLittleO {๐•œ : Type u} [NontriviallyNormedField ๐•œ] {F : Type v} [NormedAddCommGroup F] [NormedSpace ๐•œ F] {f : ๐•œ โ†’ F} {f' : F} {x : ๐•œ} : HasDerivAt f f' x โ†” (fun x' โ†ฆ f x' - f x - (x' - x) โ€ข f') =o[๐“ x] fun x' โ†ฆ x' - x

    Mathlib.Analysis.Calculus.Deriv.Basic ยท lines 287โ€“289

    Why more general: The declaration is written for maps from any nontrivially normed field into any normed space, and it measures the approximation by an error of smaller order than the increment.

    Details
    • Found by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: candidate 1 for this passage, medium confidence.
    • Re-checked by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC), challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack: it survived.
    • Record set tierA-b1b, exported 1 Nov 2026 by formal-companion d85385a.
    • Lean code: the declaration's type as Lean prints it, laid out as a header (the corpus keeps no hypothesis names), from the declaration corpus of universe u1 at commit 3dfb8e2.
    • Location key cab96b02b8be ยท pair key fdbc51786ad2.
  5. Definition ยท supporting

    Partial

    Partial: Mathlib states a more general result, but as a proved theorem, not a definition; a definition passage is formalized only by a Lean definition.

    The tangent line to a point on a differentiable curve can also be thought of as a tangent line approximation, the graph of the affine function that best approximates the original function at the given point.

    Show in article ยท Read it in context on Wikipedia

    hasDerivAt_iff_isLittleO more general

    theorem hasDerivAt_iff_isLittleO {๐•œ : Type u} [NontriviallyNormedField ๐•œ] {F : Type v} [NormedAddCommGroup F] [NormedSpace ๐•œ F] {f : ๐•œ โ†’ F} {f' : F} {x : ๐•œ} : HasDerivAt f f' x โ†” (fun x' โ†ฆ f x' - f x - (x' - x) โ€ข f') =o[๐“ x] fun x' โ†ฆ x' - x

    Mathlib.Analysis.Calculus.Deriv.Basic ยท lines 287โ€“289

    Why more general: It is stated over any nontrivially normed field and normed space, and Lean writes the approximation between the function and the affine map rather than between their graphs.

    Details
    • Found by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: candidate 1 for this passage, medium confidence.
    • Re-checked by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC), challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack: it survived.
    • Record set tierA-b1b, exported 1 Nov 2026 by formal-companion d85385a.
    • Lean code: the declaration's type as Lean prints it, laid out as a header (the corpus keeps no hypothesis names), from the declaration corpus of universe u1 at commit 3dfb8e2.
    • Location key 6eeb3b075d3e ยท pair key ed59aada39e1.
  6. Definition ยท main statement

    Partial

    Partial: Mathlib states a special case (a definition).

    Similarly, the tangent plane to a surface at a given point is the plane that "just touches" the surface at that point.

    Show in article ยท Read it in context on Wikipedia

    EuclideanGeometry.Sphere.IsTangentAt special case

    structure EuclideanGeometry.Sphere.IsTangentAt {V : Type*} {P : Type*} [NormedAddCommGroup V] [InnerProductSpace โ„ V] [MetricSpace P] [NormedAddTorsor V P] : EuclideanGeometry.Sphere P โ†’ P โ†’ AffineSubspace โ„ P โ†’ Prop

    Mathlib.Geometry.Euclidean.Sphere.Tangent ยท lines 64โ€“67

    Why a special case: Mathlib has this relation for spheres, so the surface it reaches is a sphere, and it admits affine subspaces of any dimension, the plane among them.

    Details
    • Found by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: candidate 1 for this passage, medium confidence.
    • Re-checked by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC), challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack: it survived.
    • Record set tierA-b1b, exported 1 Nov 2026 by formal-companion d85385a.
    • Lean code: the declaration's type as Lean prints it, laid out as a header (the corpus keeps no hypothesis names), from the declaration corpus of universe u1 at commit 3dfb8e2.
    • Location key b967a5e688a1 ยท pair key 94f5e0c5485d.
  7. Definition ยท main statement ยท History

    Formalized

    Formalized: Mathlib states a more general result (a Prop-valued definition: it states the claim without proving it).

    It has been dismissed and the modern definitions are equivalent to those of Leibniz, who defined the tangent line as the line through a pair of infinitely close points on the curve; in modern terminology, this is expressed as: the tangent to a curve at a point P on the curve is the limit of the line passing through two points of the curve when these two points tends to P.

    Show in article ยท Read it in context on Wikipedia

    HasStrictDerivAt more general

    def HasStrictDerivAt {๐•œ : Type u} [NontriviallyNormedField ๐•œ] {F : Type v} [AddCommGroup F] [_root_.Module ๐•œ F] [TopologicalSpace F] [ContinuousSMul ๐•œ F] : (๐•œ โ†’ F) โ†’ F โ†’ ๐•œ โ†’ Prop

    Mathlib.Analysis.Calculus.Deriv.Basic ยท lines 137โ€“138

    Why more general: Lean's definition is for maps from any nontrivially normed field into a topological module and writes the condition as f y โˆ’ f z = (y โˆ’ z)ยทfโ€ฒ + o(y โˆ’ z) while y and z both approach the point.

    Details
    • Found by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: candidate 1 for this passage, medium confidence.
    • Re-checked by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC), challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack: it survived.
    • Record set tierA-b1b, exported 1 Nov 2026 by formal-companion d85385a.
    • Lean code: the declaration's type as Lean prints it, laid out as a header (the corpus keeps no hypothesis names), from the declaration corpus of universe u1 at commit 3dfb8e2.
    • Location key 18c8a6a9817c ยท pair key 6f432511d87c.
  8. Definition ยท main statement ยท Tangent line to a plane curve

    Partial

    Partial: Mathlib states a more general result, but as a proved theorem, not a definition; a definition passage is formalized only by a Lean definition.

    The intuitive notion that a tangent line "touches" a curve can be made more explicit by considering the sequence of straight lines (secant lines) passing through two points, A and B, those that lie on the function curve. The tangent at A is the limit when point B approximates or tends to A.

    Show in article ยท Read it in context on Wikipedia

    hasDerivAt_iff_tendsto_slope more general

    theorem hasDerivAt_iff_tendsto_slope {๐•œ : Type u} [NontriviallyNormedField ๐•œ] {F : Type v} [NormedAddCommGroup F] [NormedSpace ๐•œ F] {f : ๐•œ โ†’ F} {f' : F} {x : ๐•œ} : HasDerivAt f f' x โ†” Filter.Tendsto (slope f x) (๐“[โ‰ ] x) (๐“ f')

    Mathlib.Analysis.Calculus.Deriv.Slope ยท lines 73โ€“74

    Why more general: Stated for maps from any nontrivially normed field into any normed space; Lean takes the limit of the two point slopes over points near A other than A, in place of the lines themselves.

    Details
    • Found by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: candidate 1 for this passage, high confidence.
    • Re-checked by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC), challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack: it survived.
    • Record set tierA-b1b, exported 1 Nov 2026 by formal-companion d85385a.
    • Lean code: the declaration's type as Lean prints it, laid out as a header (the corpus keeps no hypothesis names), from the declaration corpus of universe u1 at commit 3dfb8e2.
    • Location key a42365b26c36 ยท pair key daed0cf621dd.

    HasStrictDerivAt special case

    def HasStrictDerivAt {๐•œ : Type u} [NontriviallyNormedField ๐•œ] {F : Type v} [AddCommGroup F] [_root_.Module ๐•œ F] [TopologicalSpace F] [ContinuousSMul ๐•œ F] : (๐•œ โ†’ F) โ†’ F โ†’ ๐•œ โ†’ Prop

    Mathlib.Analysis.Calculus.Deriv.Basic ยท lines 137โ€“138

    Why a special case: It asks for a limit over both endpoints, a condition not every curve with a tangent at A meets, so it covers those curves alone.

    Details
    • Found by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: candidate 2 for this passage, medium confidence.
    • Re-checked by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC), challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack: it survived.
    • Record set tierA-b1b, exported 1 Nov 2026 by formal-companion d85385a.
    • Lean code: the declaration's type as Lean prints it, laid out as a header (the corpus keeps no hypothesis names), from the declaration corpus of universe u1 at commit 3dfb8e2.
    • Location key d8cb382e851a ยท pair key 57360f7d1861.
  9. Example ยท supporting ยท Tangent line to a plane curve

    Not formalized
    The tangent at A is the limit when point B approximates or tends to A. The existence and uniqueness of the tangent line depends on a certain type of mathematical smoothness, known as "differentiability." For example, if two circular arcs meet at a sharp point (a vertex) then there is no uniquely defined tangent at the vertex because the limit of the progression of secant lines depends on the direction in which "point B" approaches the vertex.

    Show in article ยท Read it in context on Wikipedia

    Searched 48 libraries โ€” not found. Which libraries, at which commits (pinned 2026-10-17).

    Details
    • Searched by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: the search receipt lists 4 queries and 2 candidates examined (receipt ad8a5e8c9730).
    • Re-checked by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC), challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack: upheld.
  10. Theorem ยท supporting ยท Tangent line to a plane curve

    Not formalized
    โ€ฆis the limit when point B approximates or tends to A. The existence and uniqueness of the tangent line depends on a certain type of mathematical smoothness, known as "differentiability." For example, if two circular arcs meet at a sharp point (a vertex) then there is no uniquely defined tangent at the vertex because the limit of the progression of secant lines depends on the direction in which "point B" approaches the vertex.

    Show in article ยท Read it in context on Wikipedia

    Searched 48 libraries โ€” not found. Which libraries, at which commits (pinned 2026-10-17).

    Details
    • Searched by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: the search receipt lists 3 queries and 2 candidates examined (receipt 3bd7e887d7f5).
    • Not re-checked: sampled out of challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack, in which Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) re-checked a sample on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC).
  11. Theorem ยท supporting ยท Tangent line to a plane curve

    Partial

    Partial: TauCeti states a special case (proved).

    At most points, the tangent touches the curve without crossing it (though it may, when continued, cross the curve at other places away from the point of tangent).

    Show in article ยท Read it in context on Wikipedia

    Real.rpow_add_mul_rpow_sub_one_mul_sub_lt_rpow special case

    theorem Real.rpow_add_mul_rpow_sub_one_mul_sub_lt_rpow {p u v : โ„} : 1 < p โ†’ 0 โ‰ค u โ†’ 0 โ‰ค v โ†’ u โ‰  v โ†’ v ^ p + p * v ^ (p - 1) * (u - v) < u ^ p

    TauCeti.Analysis.SpecialFunctions.Pow.Bounds ยท lines 69โ€“85

    Why a special case: This is the passage's claim for one family of curves only, and in a sharper quantitative form: a strict inequality at every point of the half-line rather than a qualitative claim at most points of an arbitrary curve.

    Details
    • Found by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: candidate 1 for this passage, medium confidence.
    • Re-checked by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC), challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack: it survived.
    • Record set tierA-b1b, exported 1 Nov 2026 by formal-companion d85385a.
    • Lean code: the declaration's type as Lean prints it, laid out as a header (the corpus keeps no hypothesis names), from the declaration corpus of universe u1 at commit 83245ab.
    • Location key f13504aee258 ยท pair key d84deade1541.
  12. Definition ยท main statement ยท Tangent line to a plane curve

    Not formalized
    A point where the tangent (at this point) crosses the curve is called an inflection point.

    Show in article ยท Read it in context on Wikipedia

    Searched 48 libraries โ€” not found. Which libraries, at which commits (pinned 2026-10-17).

    Details
    • Searched by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: the search receipt lists 3 queries and 1 candidates examined (receipt 77b95da80a9e).
    • Re-checked by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC), challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack: upheld.
  13. Theorem ยท supporting ยท Tangent line to a plane curve

    Not formalized
    Circles, parabolas, hyperbolas and ellipses do not have any inflection point, but more complicated curves do have, like the graph of a cubic function, which has exactly one inflection point, or a sinusoid, which has two inflection points per each period of the sine.

    Show in article ยท Read it in context on Wikipedia

    Searched 48 libraries โ€” not found. Which libraries, at which commits (pinned 2026-10-17).

    Details
    • Searched by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: the search receipt lists 3 queries and 2 candidates examined (receipt 887f6bd6aaa2).
    • Not re-checked: sampled out of challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack, in which Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) re-checked a sample on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC).
  14. Theorem ยท supporting ยท Tangent line to a plane curve

    Not formalized
    Circles, parabolas, hyperbolas and ellipses do not have any inflection point, but more complicated curves do have, like the graph of a cubic function, which has exactly one inflection point, or a sinusoid, which has two inflection points per each period of the sine.

    Show in article ยท Read it in context on Wikipedia

    Searched 48 libraries โ€” not found. Which libraries, at which commits (pinned 2026-10-17).

    Details
    • Searched by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: the search receipt lists 3 queries and 2 candidates examined (receipt 664f6eb641c5).
    • Not re-checked: sampled out of challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack, in which Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) re-checked a sample on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC).
  15. Theorem ยท supporting ยท Tangent line to a plane curve

    Not formalized
    Circles, parabolas, hyperbolas and ellipses do not have any inflection point, but more complicated curves do have, like the graph of a cubic function, which has exactly one inflection point, or a sinusoid, which has two inflection points per each period of the sine.

    Show in article ยท Read it in context on Wikipedia

    Searched 48 libraries โ€” not found. Which libraries, at which commits (pinned 2026-10-17).

    Details
    • Searched by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: the search receipt lists 3 queries and 1 candidates examined (receipt 44cec030ea44).
    • Re-checked by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC), challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack: upheld.
  16. Theorem ยท supporting ยท Tangent line to a plane curve

    Not formalized
    Circles, parabolas, hyperbolas and ellipses do not have any inflection point, but more complicated curves do have, like the graph of a cubic function, which has exactly one inflection point, or a sinusoid, which has two inflection points per each period of the sine.

    Show in article ยท Read it in context on Wikipedia

    Searched 48 libraries โ€” not found. Which libraries, at which commits (pinned 2026-10-17).

    Details
    • Searched by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: the search receipt lists 7 queries and 2 candidates examined (receipt bb76eaaa2c64).
    • Not re-checked: sampled out of challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack, in which Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) re-checked a sample on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC).
  17. Theorem ยท supporting ยท Tangent line to a plane curve

    Not formalized
    Conversely, it may happen that the curve lies entirely on one side of a straight line passing through a point on it, and yet this straight line is not a tangent line.

    Show in article ยท Read it in context on Wikipedia

    Searched 48 libraries โ€” not found. Which libraries, at which commits (pinned 2026-10-17).

    Details
    • Searched by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: the search receipt lists 4 queries and 2 candidates examined (receipt bec1e4b31cab).
    • Not re-checked: sampled out of challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack, in which Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) re-checked a sample on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC).
  18. Example ยท supporting ยท Tangent line to a plane curve

    Not formalized
    This is the case, for example, for a line passing through the vertex of a triangle and not intersecting it otherwiseโ€”where the tangent line does not exist for the reasons explained above.

    Show in article ยท Read it in context on Wikipedia

    Searched 48 libraries โ€” not found. Which libraries, at which commits (pinned 2026-10-17).

    Details
    • Searched by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: the search receipt lists 4 queries and 2 candidates examined (receipt a45ef601796d).
    • Re-checked by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC), challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack: upheld.
  19. Definition ยท supporting ยท Tangent line to a plane curve

    Not formalized
    In convex geometry, such lines are called supporting lines.

    Show in article ยท Read it in context on Wikipedia

    Searched 48 libraries โ€” not found. Which libraries, at which commits (pinned 2026-10-17).

    Details
    • Searched by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: the search receipt lists 4 queries and 2 candidates examined (receipt e2a7be0ba049).
    • Not re-checked: sampled out of challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack, in which Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) re-checked a sample on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC).
  20. Theorem ยท main statement ยท Tangent line to a plane curve โ€บ Analytical approach โ€บ Intuitive description

    Formalized

    Formalized: Mathlib states a more general result (proved).

    Suppose that a curve is given as the graph of a function, y = f(x). To find the tangent line at the point p = (a, f(a)), consider another nearby point q = (a + h, f(a + h)) on the curve. The slope of the secant line passing through p and q is equal to the difference quotient f(a + h) โˆ’ f(a)h.

    Show in article ยท Read it in context on Wikipedia

    slope_def_field more general

    theorem slope_def_field {k : Type*} [Field k] (f : k โ†’ k) (a b : k) : slope f a b = (f b - f a) / (b - a)

    Mathlib.LinearAlgebra.AffineSpace.Slope ยท lines 42โ€“43

    Why more general: Lean states it for an arbitrary field of scalars, so the passage's real graph is one of the cases it covers.

    Details
    • Found by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: candidate 1 for this passage, high confidence.
    • Re-checked by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC), challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack: it survived.
    • Record set tierA-b1b, exported 1 Nov 2026 by formal-companion d85385a.
    • Lean code: the declaration's type as Lean prints it, laid out as a header (the corpus keeps no hypothesis names), from the declaration corpus of universe u1 at commit 3dfb8e2.
    • Location key e14942a6dc5d ยท pair key de7eee362b07.
  21. Definition ยท main statement ยท Tangent line to a plane curve โ€บ Analytical approach โ€บ Intuitive description

    Partial

    Partial: Mathlib states a more general result, but as a proved theorem, not a definition; a definition passage is formalized only by a Lean definition.

    As the point q approaches p, which corresponds to making h smaller and smaller, the difference quotient should approach a certain limiting value k, which is the slope of the tangent line at the point p.

    Show in article ยท Read it in context on Wikipedia

    hasDerivAt_iff_tendsto_slope_zero more general

    theorem hasDerivAt_iff_tendsto_slope_zero {๐•œ : Type u} [NontriviallyNormedField ๐•œ] {F : Type v} [NormedAddCommGroup F] [NormedSpace ๐•œ F] {f : ๐•œ โ†’ F} {f' : F} {x : ๐•œ} : HasDerivAt f f' x โ†” Filter.Tendsto (fun t โ†ฆ tโปยน โ€ข (f (x + t) - f x)) (๐“[โ‰ ] 0) (๐“ f')

    Mathlib.Analysis.Calculus.Deriv.Slope ยท lines 82โ€“85

    Why more general: Lean writes the slope of the tangent as the derivative, and states the limit for functions into any normed space over any nontrivially normed field.

    Details
    • Found by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: candidate 1 for this passage, high confidence.
    • Re-checked by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC), challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack: it survived.
    • Record set tierA-b1b, exported 1 Nov 2026 by formal-companion d85385a.
    • Lean code: the declaration's type as Lean prints it, laid out as a header (the corpus keeps no hypothesis names), from the declaration corpus of universe u1 at commit 3dfb8e2.
    • Location key 1f215b73a5fd ยท pair key 67cf8d3ed7b3.

    hasDerivAt_iff_tendsto_slope more general

    theorem hasDerivAt_iff_tendsto_slope {๐•œ : Type u} [NontriviallyNormedField ๐•œ] {F : Type v} [NormedAddCommGroup F] [NormedSpace ๐•œ F] {f : ๐•œ โ†’ F} {f' : F} {x : ๐•œ} : HasDerivAt f f' x โ†” Filter.Tendsto (slope f x) (๐“[โ‰ ] x) (๐“ f')

    Mathlib.Analysis.Calculus.Deriv.Slope ยท lines 73โ€“74

    Why more general: Here the limit is taken along the second point of the secant rather than along the increment, and the statement is for any normed space over any nontrivially normed field.

    Details
    • Found by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: candidate 2 for this passage, high confidence.
    • Re-checked by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC), challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack: it survived.
    • Record set tierA-b1b, exported 1 Nov 2026 by formal-companion d85385a.
    • Lean code: the declaration's type as Lean prints it, laid out as a header (the corpus keeps no hypothesis names), from the declaration corpus of universe u1 at commit 3dfb8e2.
    • Location key 83ec1d33db29 ยท pair key ebe255c2d467.
  22. Theorem ยท main statement ยท Tangent line to a plane curve โ€บ Analytical approach โ€บ Intuitive description

    Not formalized
    If k is known, the equation of the tangent line can be found in the point-slope form: y โˆ’ f(a) = k(x โˆ’ a).

    Show in article ยท Read it in context on Wikipedia

    Searched 48 libraries โ€” not found. Which libraries, at which commits (pinned 2026-10-17).

    Details
    • Searched by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: the search receipt lists 4 queries and 2 candidates examined (receipt 2f5246598ea3).
    • Re-checked by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC), challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack: upheld.
  23. Theorem ยท main statement ยท Tangent line to a plane curve โ€บ Analytical approach โ€บ More rigorous description

    Partial

    Partial: Mathlib states part of this (proved).

    Suppose that the graph does not have a break or a sharp edge at p and it is neither plumb nor too wiggly near p. Then there is a unique value of k such that, as h approaches 0, the difference quotient gets closer and closer to k, and the distance between them becomes negligible compared with the size of h, if h is small enough.

    Show in article ยท Read it in context on Wikipedia

    HasDerivAt.unique states part

    theorem HasDerivAt.unique {๐•œ : Type u} [NontriviallyNormedField ๐•œ] {F : Type v} [NormedAddCommGroup F] [NormedSpace ๐•œ F] {f : ๐•œ โ†’ F} {fโ‚€' fโ‚' : F} {x : ๐•œ} : HasDerivAt f fโ‚€' x โ†’ HasDerivAt f fโ‚' x โ†’ fโ‚€' = fโ‚'

    Mathlib.Analysis.Calculus.Deriv.Basic ยท lines 397โ€“398

    Why only part: The existence of such a k comes from the passage's smoothness hypotheses, which this declaration does not supply.

    Details
    • Found by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: candidate 1 for this passage, high confidence.
    • Re-checked by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC), challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack: it survived.
    • Record set tierA-b1b, exported 1 Nov 2026 by formal-companion d85385a.
    • Lean code: the declaration's type as Lean prints it, laid out as a header (the corpus keeps no hypothesis names), from the declaration corpus of universe u1 at commit 3dfb8e2.
    • Location key 9c20fbbd7956 ยท pair key e77fc16b4031.

    hasDerivAt_iff_tendsto_slope_zero states part

    theorem hasDerivAt_iff_tendsto_slope_zero {๐•œ : Type u} [NontriviallyNormedField ๐•œ] {F : Type v} [NormedAddCommGroup F] [NormedSpace ๐•œ F] {f : ๐•œ โ†’ F} {f' : F} {x : ๐•œ} : HasDerivAt f f' x โ†” Filter.Tendsto (fun t โ†ฆ tโปยน โ€ข (f (x + t) - f x)) (๐“[โ‰ ] 0) (๐“ f')

    Mathlib.Analysis.Calculus.Deriv.Slope ยท lines 82โ€“85

    Why only part: It characterises k but does not produce it from the passage's informal hypotheses of no break, no sharp edge and no wild oscillation.

    Details
    • Found by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: candidate 2 for this passage, high confidence.
    • Re-checked by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC), challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack: it survived.
    • Record set tierA-b1b, exported 1 Nov 2026 by formal-companion d85385a.
    • Lean code: the declaration's type as Lean prints it, laid out as a header (the corpus keeps no hypothesis names), from the declaration corpus of universe u1 at commit 3dfb8e2.
    • Location key 19e8457a7985 ยท pair key 803442ff2aab.

    hasDerivAt_iff_isLittleO_nhds_zero states part

    theorem hasDerivAt_iff_isLittleO_nhds_zero {๐•œ : Type u} [NontriviallyNormedField ๐•œ] {F : Type v} [NormedAddCommGroup F] [NormedSpace ๐•œ F] {f : ๐•œ โ†’ F} {f' : F} {x : ๐•œ} : HasDerivAt f f' x โ†” (fun h โ†ฆ f (x + h) - f x - h โ€ข f') =o[๐“ 0] fun h โ†ฆ h

    Mathlib.Analysis.Calculus.Deriv.Basic ยท lines 363โ€“365

    Why only part: It states the size of the error, not the existence of the number k under the passage's hypotheses.

    Details
    • Found by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: candidate 3 for this passage, high confidence.
    • Re-checked by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC), challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack: it survived.
    • Record set tierA-b1b, exported 1 Nov 2026 by formal-companion d85385a.
    • Lean code: the declaration's type as Lean prints it, laid out as a header (the corpus keeps no hypothesis names), from the declaration corpus of universe u1 at commit 3dfb8e2.
    • Location key 31b90e673042 ยท pair key 3a6b3940abea.
  24. Definition ยท main statement ยท Tangent line to a plane curve โ€บ Analytical approach โ€บ More rigorous description

    Formalized

    Formalized: Mathlib states a more general result (a definition).

    This leads to the definition of the slope of the tangent line to the graph as the limit of the difference quotients for the function f.

    Show in article ยท Read it in context on Wikipedia

    deriv more general

    def deriv {๐•œ : Type u} [NontriviallyNormedField ๐•œ] {F : Type v} [AddCommGroup F] [_root_.Module ๐•œ F] [TopologicalSpace F] : (๐•œ โ†’ F) โ†’ ๐•œ โ†’ F

    Mathlib.Analysis.Calculus.Deriv.Basic ยท lines 154โ€“155

    Why more general: It is defined for functions into a module over any nontrivially normed field and returns zero at points where no derivative exists.

    Details
    • Found by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: candidate 1 for this passage, high confidence.
    • Re-checked by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC), challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack: it survived.
    • Record set tierA-b1b, exported 1 Nov 2026 by formal-companion d85385a.
    • Lean code: the declaration's type as Lean prints it, laid out as a header (the corpus keeps no hypothesis names), from the declaration corpus of universe u1 at commit 3dfb8e2.
    • Location key ff1b749be071 ยท pair key 4f80f407d208.

    hasDerivAt_iff_tendsto_slope_zero more general

    theorem hasDerivAt_iff_tendsto_slope_zero {๐•œ : Type u} [NontriviallyNormedField ๐•œ] {F : Type v} [NormedAddCommGroup F] [NormedSpace ๐•œ F] {f : ๐•œ โ†’ F} {f' : F} {x : ๐•œ} : HasDerivAt f f' x โ†” Filter.Tendsto (fun t โ†ฆ tโปยน โ€ข (f (x + t) - f x)) (๐“[โ‰ ] 0) (๐“ f')

    Mathlib.Analysis.Calculus.Deriv.Slope ยท lines 82โ€“85

    Why more general: It states the defining limit through the derivative predicate, for functions into any normed space over any nontrivially normed field.

    Details
    • Found by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: candidate 2 for this passage, high confidence.
    • Re-checked by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC), challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack: it survived.
    • Record set tierA-b1b, exported 1 Nov 2026 by formal-companion d85385a.
    • Lean code: the declaration's type as Lean prints it, laid out as a header (the corpus keeps no hypothesis names), from the declaration corpus of universe u1 at commit 3dfb8e2.
    • Location key 7d0399fcb4b7 ยท pair key 9a56e92aef0e.
  25. Definition ยท supporting ยท Tangent line to a plane curve โ€บ Analytical approach โ€บ More rigorous description

    Formalized

    Formalized: Mathlib states a more general result (a definition).

    This limit is the derivative of the function f at x = a, denoted f โ€ฒ(a).

    Show in article ยท Read it in context on Wikipedia

    deriv more general

    def deriv {๐•œ : Type u} [NontriviallyNormedField ๐•œ] {F : Type v} [AddCommGroup F] [_root_.Module ๐•œ F] [TopologicalSpace F] : (๐•œ โ†’ F) โ†’ ๐•œ โ†’ F

    Mathlib.Analysis.Calculus.Deriv.Basic ยท lines 154โ€“155

    Why more general: Lean builds this object over any nontrivially normed field and any normed space over it, and hands back zero at points where no derivative exists.

    Details
    • Found by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: candidate 1 for this passage, high confidence.
    • Re-checked by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC), challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack: it survived.
    • Record set tierA-b1b, exported 1 Nov 2026 by formal-companion d85385a.
    • Lean code: the declaration's type as Lean prints it, laid out as a header (the corpus keeps no hypothesis names), from the declaration corpus of universe u1 at commit 3dfb8e2.
    • Location key 943ee07c898e ยท pair key 359809babfbb.

    hasDerivAt_iff_tendsto_slope_zero more general

    theorem hasDerivAt_iff_tendsto_slope_zero {๐•œ : Type u} [NontriviallyNormedField ๐•œ] {F : Type v} [NormedAddCommGroup F] [NormedSpace ๐•œ F] {f : ๐•œ โ†’ F} {f' : F} {x : ๐•œ} : HasDerivAt f f' x โ†” Filter.Tendsto (fun t โ†ฆ tโปยน โ€ข (f (x + t) - f x)) (๐“[โ‰ ] 0) (๐“ f')

    Mathlib.Analysis.Calculus.Deriv.Slope ยท lines 82โ€“85

    Why more general: The Lean form divides the increment of f over h and lets h tend to zero through nonzero values, which is the quotient the passage writes.

    Details
    • Found by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: candidate 2 for this passage, high confidence.
    • Not re-checked: sampled out of challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack, in which Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) re-checked a sample on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC).
    • Record set tierA-b1b, exported 1 Nov 2026 by formal-companion d85385a.
    • Lean code: the declaration's type as Lean prints it, laid out as a header (the corpus keeps no hypothesis names), from the declaration corpus of universe u1 at commit 3dfb8e2.
    • Location key 7650bf06fdf8 ยท pair key 017d6ee9d808.

    hasDerivAt_iff_tendsto_slope more general

    theorem hasDerivAt_iff_tendsto_slope {๐•œ : Type u} [NontriviallyNormedField ๐•œ] {F : Type v} [NormedAddCommGroup F] [NormedSpace ๐•œ F] {f : ๐•œ โ†’ F} {f' : F} {x : ๐•œ} : HasDerivAt f f' x โ†” Filter.Tendsto (slope f x) (๐“[โ‰ ] x) (๐“ f')

    Mathlib.Analysis.Calculus.Deriv.Slope ยท lines 73โ€“74

    Why more general: Lean writes the quotient through the named slope function and takes the limit along the punctured neighbourhood of the point.

    Details
    • Found by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: candidate 3 for this passage, medium confidence.
    • Re-checked by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC), challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack: it survived.
    • Record set tierA-b1b, exported 1 Nov 2026 by formal-companion d85385a.
    • Lean code: the declaration's type as Lean prints it, laid out as a header (the corpus keeps no hypothesis names), from the declaration corpus of universe u1 at commit 3dfb8e2.
    • Location key 373659a29a94 ยท pair key 886bd02dbe53.
  26. Theorem ยท main statement ยท Tangent line to a plane curve โ€บ Analytical approach โ€บ More rigorous description

    Not formalized
    Using derivatives, the equation of the tangent line can be stated as follows: y = f(a) + fโ€ฒ(a)(x โˆ’ a).

    Show in article ยท Read it in context on Wikipedia

    Searched 48 libraries โ€” not found. Which libraries, at which commits (pinned 2026-10-17).

    Details
    • Searched by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: the search receipt lists 4 queries and 2 candidates examined (receipt 0312ed47e90c).
    • Re-checked by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC), challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack: upheld.
  27. Theorem ยท supporting ยท Tangent line to a plane curve โ€บ Analytical approach โ€บ How the method can fail

    Formalized

    Formalized: ATLAS (atlas-lean) states a more general result (proved).

    Calculus also demonstrates that there are functions and points on their graphs for which the limit determining the slope of the tangent line does not exist.

    Show in article ยท Read it in context on Wikipedia

    MathlibExt.Analysis.Calculus.NowhereDifferentiable.exists_continuous_nowhere_differentiable more general

    theorem MathlibExt.Analysis.Calculus.NowhereDifferentiable.exists_continuous_nowhere_differentiable : โˆƒ f, โˆ€ (x : โ„), ยฌDifferentiableAt โ„ (โ‡‘f) x

    MathlibExt.Analysis.Calculus.NowhereDifferentiable ยท line 358

    Why more general: The function it produces has no derivative at any real point, while the passage asks only that some function and some point behave this way.

    Details
    • Found by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: candidate 1 for this passage, high confidence.
    • Re-checked by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC), challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack: it survived.
    • Record set tierA-b1b, exported 1 Nov 2026 by formal-companion d85385a.
    • Lean code: the declaration's type as Lean prints it, laid out as a header (the corpus keeps no hypothesis names), from the declaration corpus of universe u1 at commit 64c2773.
    • Location key 08f64cac56f9 ยท pair key 49a1ef278061.

    not_differentiableAt_abs_zero more general

    theorem not_differentiableAt_abs_zero : ยฌDifferentiableAt โ„ abs 0

    Mathlib.Analysis.Calculus.Deriv.Abs ยท lines 185โ€“193

    Why more general: Lean fixes the function as the absolute value and the point as the origin, so it hands the passage a named witness.

    Details
    • Found by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: candidate 2 for this passage, high confidence.
    • Re-checked by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC), challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack: it survived.
    • Record set tierA-b1b, exported 1 Nov 2026 by formal-companion d85385a.
    • Lean code: the declaration's type as Lean prints it, laid out as a header (the corpus keeps no hypothesis names), from the declaration corpus of universe u1 at commit 3dfb8e2.
    • Location key 2359c5233859 ยท pair key 43b55aa82dd1.

    Real.not_differentiableAt_rpow_const_zero more general

    theorem Real.not_differentiableAt_rpow_const_zero {r : โ„} : r < 1 โ†’ r โ‰  0 โ†’ ยฌDifferentiableAt โ„ (fun x โ†ฆ x ^ r) 0

    Mathlib.Analysis.SpecialFunctions.Pow.Deriv ยท lines 420โ€“432

    Why more general: Lean quantifies over the exponent, so one choice of it names a function and a point of the kind the passage claims.

    Details
    • Found by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: candidate 3 for this passage, medium confidence.
    • Re-checked by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC), challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack: it survived.
    • Record set tierA-b1b, exported 1 Nov 2026 by formal-companion d85385a.
    • Lean code: the declaration's type as Lean prints it, laid out as a header (the corpus keeps no hypothesis names), from the declaration corpus of universe u1 at commit 3dfb8e2.
    • Location key 0a6eef8cdeb2 ยท pair key 3d96f0131461.
  28. Theorem ยท supporting ยท Tangent line to a plane curve โ€บ Analytical approach โ€บ How the method can fail

    Formalized

    Formalized: Mathlib states a more general result (proved).

    For these points the function f is non-differentiable.

    Show in article ยท Read it in context on Wikipedia

    hasDerivAt_iff_tendsto_slope more general

    theorem hasDerivAt_iff_tendsto_slope {๐•œ : Type u} [NontriviallyNormedField ๐•œ] {F : Type v} [NormedAddCommGroup F] [NormedSpace ๐•œ F] {f : ๐•œ โ†’ F} {f' : F} {x : ๐•œ} : HasDerivAt f f' x โ†” Filter.Tendsto (slope f x) (๐“[โ‰ ] x) (๐“ f')

    Mathlib.Analysis.Calculus.Deriv.Slope ยท lines 73โ€“74

    Why more general: Having a derivative in Lean is exactly the existence of such a value, so ruling out every limit value rules out differentiability at that point.

    Details
    • Found by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: candidate 1 for this passage, high confidence.
    • Re-checked by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC), challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack: it survived.
    • Record set tierA-b1b, exported 1 Nov 2026 by formal-companion d85385a.
    • Lean code: the declaration's type as Lean prints it, laid out as a header (the corpus keeps no hypothesis names), from the declaration corpus of universe u1 at commit 3dfb8e2.
    • Location key 8233f3667ebb ยท pair key 3c101c36ae49.

    HasDerivAt.tendsto_slope more general

    theorem HasDerivAt.tendsto_slope {๐•œ : Type u} [NontriviallyNormedField ๐•œ] {F : Type v} [NormedAddCommGroup F] [NormedSpace ๐•œ F] {f : ๐•œ โ†’ F} {f' : F} {x : ๐•œ} : HasDerivAt f f' x โ†’ Filter.Tendsto (slope f x) (๐“[โ‰ ] x) (๐“ f')

    Mathlib.Analysis.Calculus.Deriv.Slope ยท line 76

    Why more general: It runs from having a derivative to the convergence of the quotients, the direction whose contrapositive the passage asserts.

    Details
    • Found by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: candidate 2 for this passage, high confidence.
    • Re-checked by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC), challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack: it survived.
    • Record set tierA-b1b, exported 1 Nov 2026 by formal-companion d85385a.
    • Lean code: the declaration's type as Lean prints it, laid out as a header (the corpus keeps no hypothesis names), from the declaration corpus of universe u1 at commit 3dfb8e2.
    • Location key b4674bd0ed99 ยท pair key 1c9ebdeb263f.
  29. Theorem ยท supporting ยท Tangent line to a plane curve โ€บ Analytical approach โ€บ How the method can fail

    Not formalized
    The graph y = x1/3 illustrates the first possibility: here the difference quotient at a = 0 is equal to h1/3/h = hโˆ’2/3, which becomes very large as h approaches 0.

    Show in article ยท Read it in context on Wikipedia

    Searched 48 libraries โ€” not found. Which libraries, at which commits (pinned 2026-10-17).

    Details
    • Searched by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: the search receipt lists 4 queries and 2 candidates examined (receipt 7fc7ce4f8418).
    • Re-checked by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC), challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack: upheld.
  30. Theorem ยท supporting ยท Tangent line to a plane curve โ€บ Analytical approach โ€บ How the method can fail

    Not formalized
    This curve has a tangent line at the origin that is vertical.

    Show in article ยท Read it in context on Wikipedia

    Searched 48 libraries โ€” not found. Which libraries, at which commits (pinned 2026-10-17).

    Details
    • Searched by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: the search receipt lists 4 queries and 2 candidates examined (receipt 94380b09be6f).
    • Not re-checked: sampled out of challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack, in which Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) re-checked a sample on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC).
  31. Theorem ยท supporting ยท Tangent line to a plane curve โ€บ Analytical approach โ€บ How the method can fail

    Not formalized
    The graph y = x2/3 illustrates another possibility: this graph has a cusp at the origin.

    Show in article ยท Read it in context on Wikipedia

    Searched 48 libraries โ€” not found. Which libraries, at which commits (pinned 2026-10-17).

    Details
    • Searched by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: the search receipt lists 4 queries and 2 candidates examined (receipt ca0cbe4d114a).
    • Not re-checked: sampled out of challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack, in which Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) re-checked a sample on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC).
  32. Theorem ยท supporting ยท Tangent line to a plane curve โ€บ Analytical approach โ€บ How the method can fail

    Not formalized
    This means that, when h approaches 0, the difference quotient at a = 0 approaches plus or minus infinity depending on the sign of x.

    Show in article ยท Read it in context on Wikipedia

    Searched 48 libraries โ€” not found. Which libraries, at which commits (pinned 2026-10-17).

    Details
    • Searched by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: the search receipt lists 4 queries and 2 candidates examined (receipt 147e3c6ef52a).
    • Not re-checked: sampled out of challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack, in which Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) re-checked a sample on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC).
  33. Theorem ยท supporting ยท Tangent line to a plane curve โ€บ Analytical approach โ€บ How the method can fail

    Not formalized
    Thus both branches of the curve are near to the half vertical line for which y=0, but none is near to the negative part of this line.

    Show in article ยท Read it in context on Wikipedia

    Searched 48 libraries โ€” not found. Which libraries, at which commits (pinned 2026-10-17).

    Details
    • Searched by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: the search receipt lists 4 queries and 1 candidates examined (receipt 78884df7cfd1).
    • Not re-checked: sampled out of challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack, in which Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) re-checked a sample on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC).
  34. Theorem ยท supporting ยท Tangent line to a plane curve โ€บ Analytical approach โ€บ How the method can fail

    Not formalized
    Basically, there is no tangent at the origin in this case, but in some context one may consider this line as a tangent, and even, in algebraic geometry, as a double tangent.

    Show in article ยท Read it in context on Wikipedia

    Searched 48 libraries โ€” not found. Which libraries, at which commits (pinned 2026-10-17).

    Details
    • Searched by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: the search receipt lists 4 queries and 2 candidates examined (receipt ed7d6e4dfa42).
    • Not re-checked: sampled out of challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack, in which Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) re-checked a sample on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC).
  35. Theorem ยท supporting ยท Tangent line to a plane curve โ€บ Analytical approach โ€บ How the method can fail

    Partial

    Partial: Mathlib states part of this (proved).

    The graph y = |x| of the absolute value function consists of two straight lines with different slopes joined at the origin.

    Show in article ยท Read it in context on Wikipedia

    abs_of_nonneg states part

    theorem abs_of_nonneg {ฮฑ : Type*} [Lattice ฮฑ] [AddGroup ฮฑ] {a : ฮฑ} [AddLeftMono ฮฑ] : 0 โ‰ค a โ†’ |a| = a

    Mathlib.Algebra.Order.Group.Unbundled.Abs ยท line 88

    Why only part: Mathlib fixes the right-hand piece as the line y = x; the left-hand piece and the difference of the two slopes come from elsewhere.

    Details
    • Found by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: candidate 1 for this passage, medium confidence.
    • Re-checked by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC), challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack: it survived.
    • Record set tierA-b1b, exported 1 Nov 2026 by formal-companion d85385a.
    • Lean code: the declaration's type as Lean prints it, laid out as a header (the corpus keeps no hypothesis names), from the declaration corpus of universe u1 at commit 3dfb8e2.
    • Location key 773848002b02 ยท pair key 76224ff0db21.

    abs_of_nonpos states part

    theorem abs_of_nonpos {ฮฑ : Type*} [Lattice ฮฑ] [AddGroup ฮฑ] {a : ฮฑ} [AddLeftMono ฮฑ] : a โ‰ค 0 โ†’ |a| = -a

    Mathlib.Algebra.Order.Group.Unbundled.Abs ยท line 93

    Why only part: Mathlib fixes the left-hand piece as the line y = -x; together with the companion lemma the two slopes are visibly one and minus one.

    Details
    • Found by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: candidate 2 for this passage, medium confidence.
    • Re-checked by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC), challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack: it survived.
    • Record set tierA-b1b, exported 1 Nov 2026 by formal-companion d85385a.
    • Lean code: the declaration's type as Lean prints it, laid out as a header (the corpus keeps no hypothesis names), from the declaration corpus of universe u1 at commit 3dfb8e2.
    • Location key e4fb666aae27 ยท pair key 3b0fa6ad267a.
  36. Theorem ยท supporting ยท Tangent line to a plane curve โ€บ Analytical approach โ€บ How the method can fail

    Not formalized

    With community edits: Not formalized. As published it is Partial.

    As a point q approaches the origin from the right, the secant line always has slope 1.

    Show in article ยท Read it in context on Wikipedia

  37. Theorem ยท supporting ยท Tangent line to a plane curve โ€บ Analytical approach โ€บ How the method can fail

    Not formalized

    With community edits: Not formalized. As published it is Partial.

    As a point q approaches the origin from the left, the secant line always has slope โˆ’1.

    Show in article ยท Read it in context on Wikipedia

  38. Theorem ยท supporting ยท Tangent line to a plane curve โ€บ Analytical approach โ€บ How the method can fail

    Formalized

    Formalized: Mathlib states this up to a convention difference (proved).

    Therefore, there is no unique tangent to the graph at the origin.

    Show in article ยท Read it in context on Wikipedia

    not_differentiableAt_abs_zero close match

    theorem not_differentiableAt_abs_zero : ยฌDifferentiableAt โ„ abs 0

    Mathlib.Analysis.Calculus.Deriv.Abs ยท lines 185โ€“193

    Why close, not exact: Mathlib asserts the failure of real differentiability for the absolute value when the argument is zero; the article's phrase about a unique tangent is that same failure read through its own definition of a tangent by the derivative.

    Details
    • Found by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: candidate 1 for this passage, high confidence.
    • Re-checked by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC), challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack: it survived.
    • Record set tierA-b1b, exported 1 Nov 2026 by formal-companion d85385a.
    • Lean code: the declaration's type as Lean prints it, laid out as a header (the corpus keeps no hypothesis names), from the declaration corpus of universe u1 at commit 3dfb8e2.
    • Location key e98687e3360b ยท pair key 8844929c67b5.

    not_differentiableAt_norm_zero more general

    theorem not_differentiableAt_norm_zero (E : Type*) [NormedAddCommGroup E] [NormedSpace โ„ E] [Nontrivial E] : ยฌDifferentiableAt โ„ (fun x โ†ฆ โ€–xโ€–) 0

    Mathlib.Analysis.Calculus.FDeriv.Norm ยท lines 49โ€“59

    Why more general: Mathlib states this for the norm of any real normed space with more than one point; on the real line the norm and the absolute value are one notion in two encodings.

    Details
    • Found by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: candidate 2 for this passage, medium confidence.
    • Re-checked by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC), challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack: it survived.
    • Record set tierA-b1b, exported 1 Nov 2026 by formal-companion d85385a.
    • Lean code: the declaration's type as Lean prints it, laid out as a header (the corpus keeps no hypothesis names), from the declaration corpus of universe u1 at commit 3dfb8e2.
    • Location key 8ae12542b3a0 ยท pair key 6cd8ebece7c1.
  39. Definition ยท supporting ยท Tangent line to a plane curve โ€บ Analytical approach โ€บ How the method can fail

    Not formalized
    Having two different (but finite) slopes is called a corner.

    Show in article ยท Read it in context on Wikipedia

    Searched 48 libraries โ€” not found. Which libraries, at which commits (pinned 2026-10-17).

    Details
    • Searched by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: the search receipt lists 3 queries and 1 candidates examined (receipt 8fdbc61fd3ac).
    • Not re-checked: sampled out of challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack, in which Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) re-checked a sample on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC).
  40. Theorem ยท supporting ยท Tangent line to a plane curve โ€บ Analytical approach โ€บ How the method can fail

    Formalized

    Formalized: Mathlib states a more general result (proved).

    Finally, since differentiability implies continuity, the contrapositive states discontinuity implies non-differentiability.

    Show in article ยท Read it in context on Wikipedia

    DifferentiableAt.continuousAt more general

    theorem DifferentiableAt.continuousAt {๐•œ : Type*} [NontriviallyNormedField ๐•œ] {E : Type*} [AddCommGroup E] [_root_.Module ๐•œ E] [TopologicalSpace E] {F : Type*} [AddCommGroup F] [_root_.Module ๐•œ F] [TopologicalSpace F] {f : E โ†’ F} {x : E} [ContinuousAdd E] [ContinuousSMul ๐•œ E] [ContinuousAdd F] [ContinuousSMul ๐•œ F] : DifferentiableAt ๐•œ f x โ†’ ContinuousAt f x

    Mathlib.Analysis.Calculus.FDeriv.Basic ยท lines 658โ€“660

    Why more general: Mathlib records the implication from differentiability to continuity at a point; the passage states the contrapositive of that same implication, for real functions of a real variable.

    Details
    • Found by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: candidate 1 for this passage, high confidence.
    • Re-checked by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC), challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack: it survived.
    • Record set tierA-b1b, exported 1 Nov 2026 by formal-companion d85385a.
    • Lean code: the declaration's type as Lean prints it, laid out as a header (the corpus keeps no hypothesis names), from the declaration corpus of universe u1 at commit 3dfb8e2.
    • Location key 310211d7044f ยท pair key 588c4eada706.
  41. Theorem ยท supporting ยท Tangent line to a plane curve โ€บ Analytical approach โ€บ How the method can fail

    Not formalized
    Any such jump or point discontinuity will have no tangent line.

    Show in article ยท Read it in context on Wikipedia

    Searched 48 libraries โ€” not found. Which libraries, at which commits (pinned 2026-10-17).

    Details
    • Searched by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: the search receipt lists 4 queries and 2 candidates examined (receipt 41c7e8762f43).
    • Re-checked by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC), challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack: upheld.
  42. Theorem ยท supporting ยท Tangent line to a plane curve โ€บ Analytical approach โ€บ How the method can fail

    Not formalized
    This includes cases where one slope approaches positive infinity while the other approaches negative infinity, leading to an infinite jump discontinuity

    Show in article ยท Read it in context on Wikipedia

    Searched 48 libraries โ€” not found. Which libraries, at which commits (pinned 2026-10-17).

    Details
    • Searched by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: the search receipt lists 4 queries and 2 candidates examined (receipt ceb1b6d4d140).
    • Not re-checked: sampled out of challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack, in which Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) re-checked a sample on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC).
  43. Theorem ยท main statement ยท Tangent line to a plane curve โ€บ Equations

    Not formalized
    When the curve is given by y = f(x) then the slope of the tangent is dy/dx, so by the pointโ€“slope formula the equation of the tangent line at (X, Y) is y โˆ’ Y = dydx(X) โ‹… (x โˆ’ X) where (x, y) are the coordinates of any point on the tangent line, and where the derivative is evaluated at x = X.

    Show in article ยท Read it in context on Wikipedia

    Searched 48 libraries โ€” not found. Which libraries, at which commits (pinned 2026-10-17).

    Details
    • Searched by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: the search receipt lists 5 queries and 3 candidates examined (receipt e5031a0787d5).
    • Re-checked by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC), challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack: upheld.
  44. Theorem ยท main statement ยท Tangent line to a plane curve โ€บ Equations

    Formalized

    Formalized: ATLAS (atlas-lean) states a more general result (proved).

    When the curve is given by y = f(x), the tangent line's equation can also be found[14] by using polynomial division to divide fโ€‰(x) by (x โˆ’ X)2; if the remainder is denoted by g(x), then the equation of the tangent line is given by y = g(x).

    Show in article ยท Read it in context on Wikipedia

    Polynomial.existsUnique_taylor_remainder more general

    theorem Polynomial.existsUnique_taylor_remainder {R : Type*} [CommRing R] (f : R[X]) (a : R) : โˆƒ! g, f = Polynomial.C (Polynomial.eval a f) + Polynomial.C (Polynomial.eval a (Polynomial.derivative f)) * (Polynomial.X - Polynomial.C a) + g * (Polynomial.X - Polynomial.C a) ^ 2

    MathlibExt.Algebra.Polynomial.Taylor ยท line 32

    Why more general: The declaration works over an arbitrary commutative ring and additionally pins down the quotient uniquely; the degree-one part it exhibits, built from the value and the derivative at the base point, is the point-slope expression of the tangent.

    Details
    • Found by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: candidate 1 for this passage, medium confidence.
    • Re-checked by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC), challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack: it survived.
    • Record set tierA-b1b, exported 1 Nov 2026 by formal-companion d85385a.
    • Lean code: the declaration's type as Lean prints it, laid out as a header (the corpus keeps no hypothesis names), from the declaration corpus of universe u1 at commit 64c2773.
    • Location key 1fc359f4d07b ยท pair key fd4338bde566.
  45. Theorem ยท main statement ยท Tangent line to a plane curve โ€บ Equations

    Partial

    Partial: Mathlib states a special case (proved).

    When the equation of the curve is given in the form f(x, y) = 0 then the value of the slope can be found by implicit differentiation, giving dydx = โˆ’โˆ‚fโˆ‚x/โˆ‚fโˆ‚y.

    Show in article ยท Read it in context on Wikipedia

    WeierstrassCurve.Affine.slope_of_Y_ne_eq_evalEval special case

    theorem WeierstrassCurve.Affine.slope_of_Y_ne_eq_evalEval {F : Type u} [Field F] {W : WeierstrassCurve.Affine F} [DecidableEq F] {xโ‚ xโ‚‚ yโ‚ yโ‚‚ : F} : xโ‚ = xโ‚‚ โ†’ yโ‚ โ‰  W.negY xโ‚‚ yโ‚‚ โ†’ W.slope xโ‚ xโ‚‚ yโ‚ yโ‚‚ = -Polynomial.evalEval xโ‚ yโ‚ W.polynomialX / Polynomial.evalEval xโ‚ yโ‚ W.polynomialY

    Mathlib.AlgebraicGeometry.EllipticCurve.Affine.Formula ยท lines 201โ€“206

    Why a special case: The slope function at a coincident pair of points is the slope of the tangent there, and the two polynomials named are the formal partial derivatives of the curve's defining polynomial; the lemma is stated over any field while the passage speaks of real curves.

    Details
    • Found by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: candidate 1 for this passage, medium confidence.
    • Re-checked by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC), challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack: it survived.
    • Record set tierA-b1b, exported 1 Nov 2026 by formal-companion d85385a.
    • Lean code: the declaration's type as Lean prints it, laid out as a header (the corpus keeps no hypothesis names), from the declaration corpus of universe u1 at commit 3dfb8e2.
    • Location key b0e0ef2d57ba ยท pair key ea3880a9cd58.

    WeierstrassCurve.Universal.Affine.slopeOne_eq_neg_div special case

    theorem WeierstrassCurve.Universal.Affine.slopeOne_eq_neg_div : WeierstrassCurve.Universal.Affine.slopeOne = -WeierstrassCurve.Universal.polyToField WeierstrassCurve.Universal.curve.polynomialX / WeierstrassCurve.Universal.polyToField (WeierstrassCurve.ฯˆ WeierstrassCurve.Universal.curve 2)

    TauCeti.AlgebraicGeometry.EllipticCurve.DivisionPolynomial.ZSMul ยท lines 482โ€“497

    Why a special case: The second factor in the denominator is the division polynomial of index two, which is the partial derivative of the Weierstrass polynomial with respect to the ordinate.

    Details
    • Found by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: candidate 2 for this passage, medium confidence.
    • Re-checked by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC), challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack: it survived.
    • Record set tierA-b1b, exported 1 Nov 2026 by formal-companion d85385a.
    • Lean code: the declaration's type as Lean prints it, laid out as a header (the corpus keeps no hypothesis names), from the declaration corpus of universe u1 at commit 83245ab.
    • Location key e288493d6d03 ยท pair key 864b1a5407d2.
  46. Theorem ยท main statement ยท Tangent line to a plane curve โ€บ Equations

    Partial

    Partial: ATLAS (atlas-lean) states part of this (proved).

    The equation of the tangent line at a point (X,Y) such that f(X,Y) = 0 is then[13] โˆ‚fโˆ‚x(X, Y) โ‹… (x โˆ’ X) + โˆ‚fโˆ‚y(X, Y) โ‹… (y โˆ’ Y) = 0.

    Show in article ยท Read it in context on Wikipedia

    MetaMathlibExt.levelSet_tangent_vel_of_curve states part

    theorem MetaMathlibExt.levelSet_tangent_vel_of_curve {E : Type*} [NormedAddCommGroup E] [NormedSpace โ„ E] {f : E โ†’ โ„} {c : โ„} {x v : E} : DifferentiableAt โ„ f x โ†’ โˆ€ {ฮณ : โ„ โ†’ E}, ฮณ 0 = x โ†’ HasDerivAt ฮณ v 0 โ†’ (โˆ€ (t : โ„), f (ฮณ t) = c) โ†’ (fderiv โ„ f x) v = 0

    MathlibExt.Analysis.Calculus.TangentSpaceLevelSet ยท line 47

    Why only part: The declaration speaks about velocity vectors at the point, so the passage's coordinates measured from the point of tangency appear as the components of that vector.

    Details
    • Found by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: candidate 1 for this passage, medium confidence.
    • Re-checked by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC), challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack: it survived.
    • Record set tierA-b1b, exported 1 Nov 2026 by formal-companion d85385a.
    • Lean code: the declaration's type as Lean prints it, laid out as a header (the corpus keeps no hypothesis names), from the declaration corpus of universe u1 at commit 64c2773.
    • Location key 63ebc1aad53f ยท pair key 43e287464280.

    MetaMathlibExt.levelSet_curve_of_tangent_vel states part

    theorem MetaMathlibExt.levelSet_curve_of_tangent_vel {E : Type*} [NormedAddCommGroup E] [NormedSpace โ„ E] [CompleteSpace E] {f : E โ†’ โ„} {c : โ„} {x v : E} : ContDiff โ„ 1 f โ†’ f x = c โ†’ Function.Surjective โ‡‘(fderiv โ„ f x) โ†’ (fderiv โ„ f x) v = 0 โ†’ โˆƒ ฮณ, ฮณ 0 = x โˆง HasDerivAt ฮณ v 0 โˆง โˆ€ (t : โ„), f (ฮณ t) = c

    MathlibExt.Analysis.Calculus.TangentSpaceLevelSet ยท line 150

    Why only part: Surjectivity of the differential is the requirement that the two partial derivatives do not both vanish, which is the situation the passage is in.

    Details
    • Found by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: candidate 2 for this passage, medium confidence.
    • Re-checked by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC), challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack: it survived.
    • Record set tierA-b1b, exported 1 Nov 2026 by formal-companion d85385a.
    • Lean code: the declaration's type as Lean prints it, laid out as a header (the corpus keeps no hypothesis names), from the declaration corpus of universe u1 at commit 64c2773.
    • Location key d34205589687 ยท pair key 9751d3181529.
  47. Theorem ยท supporting ยท Tangent line to a plane curve โ€บ Equations

    Partial

    Partial: ATLAS (atlas-lean) states part of this (proved).

    This equation remains true if โˆ‚fโˆ‚y(X, Y) = 0, โ€ƒโˆ‚fโˆ‚x(X, Y) โ‰  0, in which case the slope of the tangent is infinite.

    Show in article ยท Read it in context on Wikipedia

    MetaMathlibExt.levelSet_curve_of_tangent_vel states part

    theorem MetaMathlibExt.levelSet_curve_of_tangent_vel {E : Type*} [NormedAddCommGroup E] [NormedSpace โ„ E] [CompleteSpace E] {f : E โ†’ โ„} {c : โ„} {x v : E} : ContDiff โ„ 1 f โ†’ f x = c โ†’ Function.Surjective โ‡‘(fderiv โ„ f x) โ†’ (fderiv โ„ f x) v = 0 โ†’ โˆƒ ฮณ, ฮณ 0 = x โˆง HasDerivAt ฮณ v 0 โˆง โˆ€ (t : โ„), f (ฮณ t) = c

    MathlibExt.Analysis.Calculus.TangentSpaceLevelSet ยท line 150

    Why only part: With the second partial zero and the first non-zero the equation reduces to the vanishing of the horizontal displacement, which is the upright line through the point.

    Details
    • Found by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: candidate 1 for this passage, medium confidence.
    • Not re-checked: sampled out of challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack, in which Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) re-checked a sample on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC).
    • Record set tierA-b1b, exported 1 Nov 2026 by formal-companion d85385a.
    • Lean code: the declaration's type as Lean prints it, laid out as a header (the corpus keeps no hypothesis names), from the declaration corpus of universe u1 at commit 64c2773.
    • Location key 750bac4dd3df ยท pair key cb5daef68e60.

    MetaMathlibExt.levelSet_tangent_vel_of_curve states part

    theorem MetaMathlibExt.levelSet_tangent_vel_of_curve {E : Type*} [NormedAddCommGroup E] [NormedSpace โ„ E] {f : E โ†’ โ„} {c : โ„} {x v : E} : DifferentiableAt โ„ f x โ†’ โˆ€ {ฮณ : โ„ โ†’ E}, ฮณ 0 = x โ†’ HasDerivAt ฮณ v 0 โ†’ (โˆ€ (t : โ„), f (ฮณ t) = c) โ†’ (fderiv โ„ f x) v = 0

    MathlibExt.Analysis.Calculus.TangentSpaceLevelSet ยท line 47

    Why only part: The conclusion forces the horizontal component of every tangent direction to vanish, which is the analytic form of the unbounded slope the passage reports.

    Details
    • Found by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: candidate 2 for this passage, medium confidence.
    • Not re-checked: sampled out of challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack, in which Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) re-checked a sample on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC).
    • Record set tierA-b1b, exported 1 Nov 2026 by formal-companion d85385a.
    • Lean code: the declaration's type as Lean prints it, laid out as a header (the corpus keeps no hypothesis names), from the declaration corpus of universe u1 at commit 64c2773.
    • Location key ce16e9cdda84 ยท pair key 4aa3263bfd1b.
  48. Theorem ยท main statement ยท Tangent line to a plane curve โ€บ Equations

    Partial

    Partial: TauCeti states part of this (a Prop-valued definition: it states the claim without proving it).

    If, however, โˆ‚fโˆ‚y(X, Y) = โˆ‚fโˆ‚x(X, Y) = 0, the tangent line is not defined and the point (X,Y) is said to be singular.

    Show in article ยท Read it in context on Wikipedia

    WeierstrassCurve.Affine.IsSingular states part

    def WeierstrassCurve.Affine.IsSingular {R : Type*} [CommRing R] : WeierstrassCurve.Affine R โ†’ R โ†’ R โ†’ Prop

    TauCeti.AlgebraicGeometry.EllipticCurve.Affine.Singular ยท lines 95โ€“96

    Why only part: The declaration attaches the name to exactly the condition the passage uses, with the vanishing of the equation playing the role of the point lying on the curve, and its partial derivatives taken formally on polynomials.

    Details
    • Found by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: candidate 1 for this passage, medium confidence.
    • Re-checked by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC), challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack: it survived.
    • Record set tierA-b1b, exported 1 Nov 2026 by formal-companion d85385a.
    • Lean code: the declaration's type as Lean prints it, laid out as a header (the corpus keeps no hypothesis names), from the declaration corpus of universe u1 at commit 83245ab.
    • Location key 3391dfd4f98b ยท pair key 22445c5316a9.

    WeierstrassCurve.Affine.Nonsingular states part

    def WeierstrassCurve.Affine.Nonsingular {R : Type r} [CommRing R] : WeierstrassCurve.Affine R โ†’ R โ†’ R โ†’ Prop

    Mathlib.AlgebraicGeometry.EllipticCurve.Affine.Basic ยท lines 211โ€“212

    Why only part: The naming is carried in negated form, and the docstring warns that the notion is intended for fields.

    Details
    • Found by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: candidate 2 for this passage, medium confidence.
    • Re-checked by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC), challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack: it survived.
    • Record set tierA-b1b, exported 1 Nov 2026 by formal-companion d85385a.
    • Lean code: the declaration's type as Lean prints it, laid out as a header (the corpus keeps no hypothesis names), from the declaration corpus of universe u1 at commit 3dfb8e2.
    • Location key 0d10f5979eed ยท pair key e964d7b04cc3.
  49. Theorem ยท main statement ยท Tangent line to a plane curve โ€บ Equations

    Formalized

    Formalized: Mathlib states a more general result (proved).

    Specifically, let the homogeneous equation of the curve be g(x, y, z) = 0 where g is a homogeneous function of degree n. Then, if (X, Y, Z) lies on the curve, Euler's theorem implies โˆ‚gโˆ‚x โ‹… X + โˆ‚gโˆ‚y โ‹… Y + โˆ‚gโˆ‚z โ‹… Z = ng(X, Y, Z) = 0. It follows that the homogeneous equation of the tangent line is

    Show in article ยท Read it in context on Wikipedia

    MvPolynomial.IsHomogeneous.sum_X_mul_pderiv more general

    theorem MvPolynomial.IsHomogeneous.sum_X_mul_pderiv {R : Type*} {ฯƒ : Type*} [CommSemiring R] {ฯ† : MvPolynomial ฯƒ R} [Fintype ฯƒ] {n : โ„•} : ฯ†.IsHomogeneous n โ†’ โˆ‘ i, MvPolynomial.X i * (MvPolynomial.pderiv i) ฯ† = n โ€ข ฯ†

    Mathlib.RingTheory.MvPolynomial.EulerIdentity ยท lines 73โ€“75

    Why more general: Mathlib records Euler's identity as an equality of polynomials; the passage reads the same identity off at one point lying on the curve.

    Details
    • Found by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: candidate 1 for this passage, medium confidence.
    • Re-checked by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC), challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack: it survived.
    • Record set tierA-b1b, exported 1 Nov 2026 by formal-companion d85385a.
    • Lean code: the declaration's type as Lean prints it, laid out as a header (the corpus keeps no hypothesis names), from the declaration corpus of universe u1 at commit 3dfb8e2.
    • Location key 654fdf9059ab ยท pair key a567dd533926.
  50. Theorem ยท main statement ยท Tangent line to a plane curve โ€บ Equations

    Not formalized
    Then, if (X, Y, Z) lies on the curve, Euler's theorem implies โˆ‚gโˆ‚x โ‹… X + โˆ‚gโˆ‚y โ‹… Y + โˆ‚gโˆ‚z โ‹… Z = ng(X, Y, Z) = 0. It follows that the homogeneous equation of the tangent line is โˆ‚gโˆ‚x(X, Y, Z) โ‹… x + โˆ‚gโˆ‚y(X, Y, Z) โ‹… y + โˆ‚gโˆ‚z(X, Y, Z) โ‹… z = 0.

    Show in article ยท Read it in context on Wikipedia

    Searched 48 libraries โ€” not found. Which libraries, at which commits (pinned 2026-10-17).

    Details
    • Searched by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: the search receipt lists 4 queries and 2 candidates examined (receipt 2405c15371f7).
    • Re-checked by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC), challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack: upheld.
  51. Notation ยท supporting ยท Tangent line to a plane curve โ€บ Equations

    Formalized

    Formalized: Mathlib states a more general result (a definition).

    To apply this to algebraic curves, write f(x, y) as f = un + un โˆ’ 1 + โ€ฆ + u1 + u0 where each ur is the sum of all terms of degree r.

    Show in article ยท Read it in context on Wikipedia

    MvPolynomial.sum_homogeneousComponent more general

    theorem MvPolynomial.sum_homogeneousComponent {ฯƒ : Type*} {R : Type*} [CommSemiring R] (ฯ† : MvPolynomial ฯƒ R) : โˆ‘ i โˆˆ Finset.range (ฯ†.totalDegree + 1), (MvPolynomial.homogeneousComponent i) ฯ† = ฯ†

    Mathlib.RingTheory.MvPolynomial.Homogeneous ยท lines 558โ€“563

    Why more general: Lean sums the pieces from degree zero up to the total degree of f, which is the same list of summands the passage writes down from the top degree downwards.

    Details
    • Found by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: candidate 1 for this passage, high confidence.
    • Re-checked by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC), challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack: it survived.
    • Record set tierA-b1b, exported 1 Nov 2026 by formal-companion d85385a.
    • Lean code: the declaration's type as Lean prints it, laid out as a header (the corpus keeps no hypothesis names), from the declaration corpus of universe u1 at commit 3dfb8e2.
    • Location key 6ce5222aff1a ยท pair key b0bcb18002d2.

    MvPolynomial.homogeneousComponent more general

    def MvPolynomial.homogeneousComponent {ฯƒ : Type*} {R : Type*} [CommSemiring R] : โ„• โ†’ MvPolynomial ฯƒ R โ†’โ‚—[R] MvPolynomial ฯƒ R

    Mathlib.RingTheory.MvPolynomial.Homogeneous ยท lines 512โ€“513

    Why more general: This is the named object the passage's notation introduces, packaged in Lean as a linear map picking out the part of a given degree.

    Details
    • Found by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: candidate 2 for this passage, high confidence.
    • Re-checked by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC), challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack: it survived.
    • Record set tierA-b1b, exported 1 Nov 2026 by formal-companion d85385a.
    • Lean code: the declaration's type as Lean prints it, laid out as a header (the corpus keeps no hypothesis names), from the declaration corpus of universe u1 at commit 3dfb8e2.
    • Location key 24b5de1434ae ยท pair key 014625fb0114.

    MvPolynomial.homogeneousComponent_apply more general

    theorem MvPolynomial.homogeneousComponent_apply {ฯƒ : Type*} {R : Type*} [CommSemiring R] (n : โ„•) (ฯ† : MvPolynomial ฯƒ R) : (MvPolynomial.homogeneousComponent n) ฯ† = โˆ‘ d โˆˆ ฯ†.support with Finsupp.degree d = n, (MvPolynomial.monomial d) (ฯ†.coeff d)

    Mathlib.RingTheory.MvPolynomial.Homogeneous ยท lines 530โ€“533

    Why more general: Lean spells the piece out as a sum of the monomials of f whose exponents add up to the given degree.

    Details
    • Found by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: candidate 3 for this passage, high confidence.
    • Re-checked by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC), challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack: it survived.
    • Record set tierA-b1b, exported 1 Nov 2026 by formal-companion d85385a.
    • Lean code: the declaration's type as Lean prints it, laid out as a header (the corpus keeps no hypothesis names), from the declaration corpus of universe u1 at commit 3dfb8e2.
    • Location key a1ac8124e03f ยท pair key a17f0a93635d.
  52. Construction ยท supporting ยท Tangent line to a plane curve โ€บ Equations

    Partial

    Partial: Mathlib states a special case (a definition).

    The homogeneous equation of the curve is then g = un + un โˆ’ 1z + โ€ฆ + u1zn โˆ’ 1 + u0zn = 0.

    Show in article ยท Read it in context on Wikipedia

    Polynomial.homogenize special case

    def Polynomial.homogenize {R : Type*} [CommSemiring R] : R[X] โ†’ โ„• โ†’ MvPolynomial (Fin 2) R

    Mathlib.Algebra.Polynomial.Homogenize ยท lines 40โ€“41

    Why a special case: Lean builds the form in two variables, one affine variable and the new one, where the passage has two affine variables and the new one.

    Details
    • Found by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: candidate 1 for this passage, medium confidence.
    • Re-checked by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC), challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack: it survived.
    • Record set tierA-b1b, exported 1 Nov 2026 by formal-companion d85385a.
    • Lean code: the declaration's type as Lean prints it, laid out as a header (the corpus keeps no hypothesis names), from the declaration corpus of universe u1 at commit 3dfb8e2.
    • Location key 3fbe50a88964 ยท pair key 13ad397b8d6a.
  53. Theorem ยท main statement ยท Tangent line to a plane curve โ€บ Equations

    Not formalized
    Applying the equation above and setting z=1 produces โˆ‚fโˆ‚x(X, Y) โ‹… x + โˆ‚fโˆ‚y(X, Y) โ‹… y + โˆ‚gโˆ‚z(X, Y, 1) = 0 as the equation of the tangent line.[16]

    Show in article ยท Read it in context on Wikipedia

    Searched 48 libraries โ€” not found. Which libraries, at which commits (pinned 2026-10-17).

    Details
    • Searched by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: the search receipt lists 3 queries and 2 candidates examined (receipt 24ebc13a89ab).
    • Re-checked by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC), challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack: upheld.
  54. Theorem ยท main statement ยท Tangent line to a plane curve โ€บ Equations

    Not formalized
    If the curve is given parametrically by x = x(t), โ€ƒy = y(t) then the slope of the tangent is dydx = dydt/dxdt giving the equation for the tangent line at t = T, โ€‰X = x(T), โ€‰Y = y(T) as[17] dxdt(T) โ‹… (y โˆ’ Y) = dydt(T) โ‹… (x โˆ’ X).

    Show in article ยท Read it in context on Wikipedia

    Searched 48 libraries โ€” not found. Which libraries, at which commits (pinned 2026-10-17).

    Details
    • Searched by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: the search receipt lists 5 queries and 2 candidates examined (receipt 31078c73d1e3).
    • Re-checked by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC), challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack: upheld.
  55. Theorem ยท supporting ยท Tangent line to a plane curve โ€บ Equations

    Not formalized
    If dxdt(T) = dydt(T) = 0, the tangent line is not defined.

    Show in article ยท Read it in context on Wikipedia

    Searched 48 libraries โ€” not found. Which libraries, at which commits (pinned 2026-10-17).

    Details
    • Searched by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: the search receipt lists 3 queries and 2 candidates examined (receipt 2eeb8b2e5e70).
    • Not re-checked: sampled out of challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack, in which Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) re-checked a sample on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC).
  56. Definition ยท main statement ยท Tangent line to a plane curve โ€บ Normal line to a curve

    Not formalized
    The line perpendicular to the tangent line to a curve at the point of tangency is called the normal line to the curve at that point.

    Show in article ยท Read it in context on Wikipedia

    Searched 48 libraries โ€” not found. Which libraries, at which commits (pinned 2026-10-17).

    Details
    • Searched by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: the search receipt lists 3 queries and 2 candidates examined (receipt 9e3ef83d973f).
    • Re-checked by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC), challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack: upheld.
  57. Theorem ยท supporting ยท Tangent line to a plane curve โ€บ Normal line to a curve

    Not formalized
    The slopes of perpendicular lines have product โˆ’1, so if the equation of the curve is y = f(x) then slope of the normal line is

    Show in article ยท Read it in context on Wikipedia

    Searched 48 libraries โ€” not found. Which libraries, at which commits (pinned 2026-10-17).

    Details
    • Searched by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: the search receipt lists 4 queries and 2 candidates examined (receipt db4dcbbf480a).
    • Not re-checked: sampled out of challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack, in which Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) re-checked a sample on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC).
  58. Theorem ยท main statement ยท Tangent line to a plane curve โ€บ Normal line to a curve

    Not formalized
    The slopes of perpendicular lines have product โˆ’1, so if the equation of the curve is y = f(x) then slope of the normal line is โˆ’1/dydx and it follows that the equation of the normal line at (X, Y) is (x โˆ’ X) + dydx(y โˆ’ Y) = 0.

    Show in article ยท Read it in context on Wikipedia

    Searched 48 libraries โ€” not found. Which libraries, at which commits (pinned 2026-10-17).

    Details
    • Searched by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: the search receipt lists 4 queries and 2 candidates examined (receipt c834090ee7b0).
    • Re-checked by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC), challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack: upheld.
  59. Theorem ยท main statement ยท Tangent line to a plane curve โ€บ Normal line to a curve

    Not formalized
    Similarly, if the equation of the curve has the form f(x, y) = 0 then the equation of the normal line is given by[18] โˆ‚fโˆ‚y(x โˆ’ X) โˆ’ โˆ‚fโˆ‚x(y โˆ’ Y) = 0.

    Show in article ยท Read it in context on Wikipedia

    Searched 48 libraries โ€” not found. Which libraries, at which commits (pinned 2026-10-17).

    Details
    • Searched by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: the search receipt lists 3 queries and 1 candidates examined (receipt b3b9e297ca2f).
    • Re-checked by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC), challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack: upheld.
  60. Theorem ยท main statement ยท Tangent line to a plane curve โ€บ Normal line to a curve

    Not formalized
    If the curve is given parametrically by x = x(t), โ€ƒy = y(t) then the equation of the normal line is[17] dxdt(x โˆ’ X) + dydt(y โˆ’ Y) = 0.

    Show in article ยท Read it in context on Wikipedia

    Searched 48 libraries โ€” not found. Which libraries, at which commits (pinned 2026-10-17).

    Details
    • Searched by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: the search receipt lists 3 queries and 0 candidates examined (receipt 3789c91696eb).
    • Re-checked by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC), challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack: upheld.
  61. Definition ยท main statement ยท Tangent line to a plane curve โ€บ Angle between curves

    Not formalized
    The angle between two curves at a point where they intersect is defined as the angle between their tangent lines at that point.

    Show in article ยท Read it in context on Wikipedia

    Searched 48 libraries โ€” not found. Which libraries, at which commits (pinned 2026-10-17).

    Details
    • Searched by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: the search receipt lists 3 queries and 1 candidates examined (receipt 8b4277b4211a).
    • Re-checked by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC), challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack: upheld.
  62. Definition ยท main statement ยท Tangent line to a plane curve โ€บ Angle between curves

    Not formalized
    More specifically, two curves are said to be tangent at a point if they have the same tangent at a point, and orthogonal if their tangent lines are orthogonal.

    Show in article ยท Read it in context on Wikipedia

    Searched 48 libraries โ€” not found. Which libraries, at which commits (pinned 2026-10-17).

    Details
    • Searched by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: the search receipt lists 4 queries and 3 candidates examined (receipt d60c68e58751).
    • Re-checked by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC), challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack: upheld.
  63. Theorem ยท supporting ยท Tangent line to a plane curve โ€บ Multiple tangents at a point

    Not formalized
    In this case there may be two or more branches of the curve that pass through the point, each branch having its own tangent line.

    Show in article ยท Read it in context on Wikipedia

    Searched 48 libraries โ€” not found. Which libraries, at which commits (pinned 2026-10-17).

    Details
    • Searched by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: the search receipt lists 3 queries and 1 candidates examined (receipt 0ce6aa596937).
    • Re-checked by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC), challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack: upheld.
  64. Construction ยท main statement ยท Tangent line to a plane curve โ€บ Multiple tangents at a point

    Not formalized
    When the point is the origin, the equations of these lines can be found for algebraic curves by factoring the equation formed by eliminating all but the lowest degree terms from the original equation.

    Show in article ยท Read it in context on Wikipedia

    Searched 48 libraries โ€” not found. Which libraries, at which commits (pinned 2026-10-17).

    Details
    • Searched by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: the search receipt lists 3 queries and 2 candidates examined (receipt 53b6d5c03130).
    • Re-checked by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC), challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack: upheld.
  65. Theorem ยท supporting ยท Tangent line to a plane curve โ€บ Multiple tangents at a point

    Formalized

    Formalized: Mathlib states a more general result (proved).

    Since any point can be made the origin by a change of variables (or by translating the curve) this gives a method for finding the tangent lines at any singular point.

    Show in article ยท Read it in context on Wikipedia

    AddAction.exists_vadd_eq more general

    theorem AddAction.exists_vadd_eq (M : Type*) {ฮฑ : Type*} [VAdd M ฮฑ] [AddAction.IsPretransitive M ฮฑ] (x y : ฮฑ) : โˆƒ m, m +แตฅ x = y

    Mathlib.Algebra.Group.Action.Pretransitive ยท line 74

    Why more general: Mathlib states this for an arbitrary pretransitive additive action rather than for the plane alone, and the plane's translations are one such action.

    Details
    • Found by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: candidate 1 for this passage, medium confidence.
    • Re-checked by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC), challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack: it survived.
    • Record set tierA-b1b, exported 1 Nov 2026 by formal-companion d85385a.
    • Lean code: the declaration's type as Lean prints it, laid out as a header (the corpus keeps no hypothesis names), from the declaration corpus of universe u1 at commit 3dfb8e2.
    • Location key a3bb3c618c16 ยท pair key 3f99298a7c34.
  66. Example ยท supporting ยท Tangent line to a plane curve โ€บ Multiple tangents at a point

    Not formalized
    For example, the equation of the limaรงon trisectrix shown to the right is (x2 + y2 โˆ’ 2ax)2 = a2(x2 + y2).

    Show in article ยท Read it in context on Wikipedia

    Searched 48 libraries โ€” not found. Which libraries, at which commits (pinned 2026-10-17).

    Details
    • Searched by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: the search receipt lists 3 queries and 0 candidates examined (receipt 7edfe23f2409).
    • Not re-checked: sampled out of challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack, in which Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) re-checked a sample on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC).
  67. Theorem ยท supporting ยท Tangent line to a plane curve โ€บ Multiple tangents at a point

    Not formalized
    Expanding this and eliminating all but terms of degree 2 gives a2(3x2 โˆ’ y2) = 0 which, when factored, becomes y = ยฑโˆš3x.

    Show in article ยท Read it in context on Wikipedia

    Searched 48 libraries โ€” not found. Which libraries, at which commits (pinned 2026-10-17).

    Details
    • Searched by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: the search receipt lists 3 queries and 0 candidates examined (receipt a797c077ecd8).
    • Re-checked by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC), challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack: upheld.
  68. Theorem ยท main statement ยท Tangent line to a plane curve โ€บ Multiple tangents at a point

    Not formalized
    So these are the equations of the two tangent lines through the origin.

    Show in article ยท Read it in context on Wikipedia

    Searched 48 libraries โ€” not found. Which libraries, at which commits (pinned 2026-10-17).

    Details
    • Searched by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: the search receipt lists 3 queries and 0 candidates examined (receipt 50b1cd922a87).
    • Re-checked by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC), challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack: upheld.
  69. Theorem ยท supporting ยท Tangent line to a plane curve โ€บ Multiple tangents at a point

    Not formalized

    With community edits: Not formalized. As published it is Partial.

    When the curve is not self-crossing, the tangent at a reference point may still not be uniquely defined because the curve is not differentiable at that point although it is differentiable elsewhere.

    Show in article ยท Read it in context on Wikipedia

  70. Definition ยท main statement ยท Tangent line to a plane curve โ€บ Multiple tangents at a point

    Not formalized
    In this case the left and right derivatives are defined as the limits of the derivative as the point at which it is evaluated approaches the reference point from respectively the left (lower values) or the right (higher values).

    Show in article ยท Read it in context on Wikipedia

    Searched 48 libraries โ€” not found. Which libraries, at which commits (pinned 2026-10-17).

    Details
    • Searched by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: the search receipt lists 3 queries and 0 candidates examined (receipt c4e7676a2ca3).
    • Re-checked by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC), challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack: upheld.
  71. Example ยท supporting ยท Tangent line to a plane curve โ€บ Multiple tangents at a point

    Formalized

    Formalized: Mathlib states this exactly (proved).

    For example, the curve y = |x | is not differentiable at x = 0: its left and right derivatives have respective slopes โˆ’1 and 1; the tangents at that point with those slopes are called the left and right tangents.

    Show in article ยท Read it in context on Wikipedia

    not_differentiableAt_abs_zero exact match

    theorem not_differentiableAt_abs_zero : ยฌDifferentiableAt โ„ abs 0

    Mathlib.Analysis.Calculus.Deriv.Abs ยท lines 185โ€“193

    Details
    • Found by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: candidate 1 for this passage, high confidence.
    • Re-checked by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC), challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack: it survived.
    • Record set tierA-b1b, exported 1 Nov 2026 by formal-companion d85385a.
    • Lean code: the declaration's type as Lean prints it, laid out as a header (the corpus keeps no hypothesis names), from the declaration corpus of universe u1 at commit 3dfb8e2.
    • Location key d64890fc4269 ยท pair key e2943ea10864.

    not_differentiableAt_norm_zero more general

    theorem not_differentiableAt_norm_zero (E : Type*) [NormedAddCommGroup E] [NormedSpace โ„ E] [Nontrivial E] : ยฌDifferentiableAt โ„ (fun x โ†ฆ โ€–xโ€–) 0

    Mathlib.Analysis.Calculus.FDeriv.Norm ยท lines 49โ€“59

    Why more general: It is stated for the norm of any real normed space of more than one point, and the passage's curve is the case of the real line.

    Details
    • Found by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: candidate 2 for this passage, high confidence.
    • Re-checked by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC), challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack: it survived.
    • Record set tierA-b1b, exported 1 Nov 2026 by formal-companion d85385a.
    • Lean code: the declaration's type as Lean prints it, laid out as a header (the corpus keeps no hypothesis names), from the declaration corpus of universe u1 at commit 3dfb8e2.
    • Location key 703f26d37b02 ยท pair key 3afd08a0a7e3.
  72. Theorem ยท supporting ยท Tangent line to a plane curve โ€บ Multiple tangents at a point

    Partial

    Partial: Mathlib states part of this (proved).

    For example, the curve y = |x | is not differentiable at x = 0: its left and right derivatives have respective slopes โˆ’1 and 1; the tangents at that point with those slopes are called the left and right tangents.

    Show in article ยท Read it in context on Wikipedia

    deriv_abs_neg states part

    theorem deriv_abs_neg {x : โ„} : x < 0 โ†’ deriv (fun x โ†ฆ |x|) x = -1

    Mathlib.Analysis.Calculus.Deriv.Abs ยท line 195

    Why only part: It gives the slope on the whole left half line, which is the limit the passage calls the left derivative, and says nothing about the right side.

    Details
    • Found by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: candidate 1 for this passage, medium confidence.
    • Not re-checked: sampled out of challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack, in which Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) re-checked a sample on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC).
    • Record set tierA-b1b, exported 1 Nov 2026 by formal-companion d85385a.
    • Lean code: the declaration's type as Lean prints it, laid out as a header (the corpus keeps no hypothesis names), from the declaration corpus of universe u1 at commit 3dfb8e2.
    • Location key 57aa2bc202c5 ยท pair key 680784b64083.

    deriv_abs_pos states part

    theorem deriv_abs_pos {x : โ„} : 0 < x โ†’ deriv (fun x โ†ฆ |x|) x = 1

    Mathlib.Analysis.Calculus.Deriv.Abs ยท line 197

    Why only part: It gives the slope on the whole right half line, which is the limit the passage calls the right derivative, and says nothing about the left side.

    Details
    • Found by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: candidate 2 for this passage, medium confidence.
    • Not re-checked: sampled out of challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack, in which Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) re-checked a sample on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC).
    • Record set tierA-b1b, exported 1 Nov 2026 by formal-companion d85385a.
    • Lean code: the declaration's type as Lean prints it, laid out as a header (the corpus keeps no hypothesis names), from the declaration corpus of universe u1 at commit 3dfb8e2.
    • Location key 748d86b558a1 ยท pair key 5e8764474507.

    deriv_abs states part

    theorem deriv_abs (x : โ„) : deriv (fun x โ†ฆ |x|) x = โ†‘(SignType.sign x)

    Mathlib.Analysis.Calculus.Deriv.Abs ยท lines 202โ€“205

    Why only part: It records the derivative at every point at once through the sign function, so reading off the two slopes still needs the values of the sign.

    Details
    • Found by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: candidate 3 for this passage, medium confidence.
    • Not re-checked: sampled out of challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack, in which Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) re-checked a sample on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC).
    • Record set tierA-b1b, exported 1 Nov 2026 by formal-companion d85385a.
    • Lean code: the declaration's type as Lean prints it, laid out as a header (the corpus keeps no hypothesis names), from the declaration corpus of universe u1 at commit 3dfb8e2.
    • Location key 3135a30f06af ยท pair key 4749c4192e09.
  73. Definition ยท main statement ยท Tangent line to a plane curve โ€บ Multiple tangents at a point

    Not formalized
    For example, the curve y = |x | is not differentiable at x = 0: its left and right derivatives have respective slopes โˆ’1 and 1; the tangents at that point with those slopes are called the left and right tangents.

    Show in article ยท Read it in context on Wikipedia

    Searched 48 libraries โ€” not found. Which libraries, at which commits (pinned 2026-10-17).

    Details
    • Searched by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: the search receipt lists 4 queries and 3 candidates examined (receipt 304021c1b9bf).
    • Re-checked by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC), challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack: upheld.
  74. Theorem ยท supporting ยท Tangent line to a plane curve โ€บ Multiple tangents at a point

    Not formalized
    Sometimes the slopes of the left and right tangent lines are equal, so the tangent lines coincide.

    Show in article ยท Read it in context on Wikipedia

    Searched 48 libraries โ€” not found. Which libraries, at which commits (pinned 2026-10-17).

    Details
    • Searched by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: the search receipt lists 4 queries and 2 candidates examined (receipt 8b3c55d35eaf).
    • Not re-checked: sampled out of challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack, in which Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) re-checked a sample on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC).
  75. Theorem ยท supporting ยท Tangent line to a plane curve โ€บ Multiple tangents at a point

    Formalized

    Formalized: Mathlib states a more general result (proved).

    Sometimes the slopes of the left and right tangent lines are equal, so the tangent lines coincide.

    Show in article ยท Read it in context on Wikipedia

    AffineSubspace.eq_iff_direction_eq_of_mem more general

    theorem AffineSubspace.eq_iff_direction_eq_of_mem {k : Type*} {V : Type*} {P : Type*} [Ring k] [AddCommGroup V] [_root_.Module k V] [AddTorsor V P] {sโ‚ sโ‚‚ : AffineSubspace k P} {p : P} : p โˆˆ sโ‚ โ†’ p โˆˆ sโ‚‚ โ†’ (sโ‚ = sโ‚‚ โ†” sโ‚.direction = sโ‚‚.direction)

    Mathlib.LinearAlgebra.AffineSpace.AffineSubspace.Defs ยท lines 438โ€“440

    Why more general: Mathlib states the fact as an equivalence for arbitrary affine subspaces over any ring, while the passage uses only its forward half for two lines in the real plane; in the plane a line's slope and its direction submodule record the same datum.

    Details
    • Found by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: candidate 1 for this passage, medium confidence.
    • Re-checked by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC), challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack: it survived.
    • Record set tierA-b1b, exported 1 Nov 2026 by formal-companion d85385a.
    • Lean code: the declaration's type as Lean prints it, laid out as a header (the corpus keeps no hypothesis names), from the declaration corpus of universe u1 at commit 3dfb8e2.
    • Location key 2370094397e2 ยท pair key 97dd3e38d23b.
  76. Example ยท supporting ยท Tangent line to a plane curve โ€บ Multiple tangents at a point

    Not formalized
    This is true, for example, for the curve y = x 2/3, for which both the left and right derivatives at x = 0 are infinite; both the left and right tangent lines have equation x = 0.

    Show in article ยท Read it in context on Wikipedia

    Searched 48 libraries โ€” not found. Which libraries, at which commits (pinned 2026-10-17).

    Details
    • Searched by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: the search receipt lists 4 queries and 3 candidates examined (receipt 9609c5a25fd2).
    • Not re-checked: sampled out of challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack, in which Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) re-checked a sample on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC).
  77. Theorem ยท supporting ยท Tangent line to a plane curve โ€บ Multiple tangents at a point

    Not formalized
    This is true, for example, for the curve y = x 2/3, for which both the left and right derivatives at x = 0 are infinite; both the left and right tangent lines have equation x = 0.

    Show in article ยท Read it in context on Wikipedia

    Searched 48 libraries โ€” not found. Which libraries, at which commits (pinned 2026-10-17).

    Details
    • Searched by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: the search receipt lists 3 queries and 2 candidates examined (receipt e8ac77a68e04).
    • Not re-checked: sampled out of challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack, in which Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) re-checked a sample on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC).
  78. Definition ยท main statement ยท Tangent line to a space curve

    Formalized

    Formalized: Mathlib states a more general result (a definition).

    In mathematics, a tangent vector is a vector that is tangent to a curve or surface at a given point.

    Show in article ยท Read it in context on Wikipedia

    TangentSpace more general

    def TangentSpace {๐•œ : Type*} [inst : NontriviallyNormedField ๐•œ] {E : Type u} [NormedAddCommGroup E] [NormedSpace ๐•œ E] {H : Type*} [TopologicalSpace H] : ModelWithCorners ๐•œ E H โ†’ {M : Type*} โ†’ [TopologicalSpace M] โ†’ [ChartedSpace H M] โ†’ M โ†’ Type u

    Mathlib.Geometry.Manifold.IsManifold.Basic ยท lines 1033โ€“1042

    Why more general: Mathlib builds the fibre over an arbitrary nontrivially normed field and an arbitrary model with corners, so it covers the passage's real curves and surfaces alongside much else.

    Details
    • Found by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: candidate 1 for this passage, medium confidence.
    • Re-checked by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC), challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack: it survived.
    • Record set tierA-b1b, exported 1 Nov 2026 by formal-companion d85385a.
    • Lean code: the declaration's type as Lean prints it, laid out as a header (the corpus keeps no hypothesis names), from the declaration corpus of universe u1 at commit 3dfb8e2.
    • Location key 4aeb63177146 ยท pair key 9aa790de55fd.

    TauCeti.Manifold.curveVelocity special case

    def TauCeti.Manifold.curveVelocity {๐•œ : Type*} [NontriviallyNormedField ๐•œ] {E : Type*} [NormedAddCommGroup E] [NormedSpace ๐•œ E] {H : Type*} [TopologicalSpace H] (I : ModelWithCorners ๐•œ E H) {M : Type*} [TopologicalSpace M] [ChartedSpace H M] (ฮณ : ๐•œ โ†’ M) (t : ๐•œ) : TangentSpace I (ฮณ t)

    TauCeti.Geometry.Manifold.MFDeriv.Curve ยท lines 131โ€“132

    Why a special case: It lands in the tangent space at the curve's value, so it is the curve half of the passage and leaves the surface case to the tangent space itself.

    Details
    • Found by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: candidate 2 for this passage, medium confidence.
    • Re-checked by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC), challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack: it survived.
    • Record set tierA-b1b, exported 1 Nov 2026 by formal-companion d85385a.
    • Lean code: the declaration's type as Lean prints it, laid out as a header (the corpus keeps no hypothesis names), from the declaration corpus of universe u1 at commit 83245ab.
    • Location key 885fa596379b ยท pair key 7824f8db9bc5.
  79. Definition ยท main statement ยท Tangent line to a space curve

    Formalized

    Formalized: Mathlib states a more general result (a definition).

    More generally, tangent vectors are elements of a tangent space of a differentiable manifold.

    Show in article ยท Read it in context on Wikipedia

    TangentSpace more general

    def TangentSpace {๐•œ : Type*} [inst : NontriviallyNormedField ๐•œ] {E : Type u} [NormedAddCommGroup E] [NormedSpace ๐•œ E] {H : Type*} [TopologicalSpace H] : ModelWithCorners ๐•œ E H โ†’ {M : Type*} โ†’ [TopologicalSpace M] โ†’ [ChartedSpace H M] โ†’ M โ†’ Type u

    Mathlib.Geometry.Manifold.IsManifold.Basic ยท lines 1033โ€“1042

    Why more general: Mathlib indexes the construction by an arbitrary nontrivially normed field and an arbitrary model with corners, which covers the passage's real differentiable manifolds and more besides.

    Details
    • Found by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: candidate 1 for this passage, high confidence.
    • Re-checked by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC), challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack: it survived.
    • Record set tierA-b1b, exported 1 Nov 2026 by formal-companion d85385a.
    • Lean code: the declaration's type as Lean prints it, laid out as a header (the corpus keeps no hypothesis names), from the declaration corpus of universe u1 at commit 3dfb8e2.
    • Location key 3c2c35029022 ยท pair key 8b71fc12690e.
  80. Definition ยท main statement ยท Tangent line to a space curve

    Formalized

    Formalized, by a community edit: Mathlib states this up to a convention difference (a definition).

    Formally, a tangent vector at the point x is a linear derivation of the algebra defined by the set of germs at x.

    Show in article ยท Read it in context on Wikipedia

    PointDerivation close match

    abbrev PointDerivation {๐•œ : Type u_1} [inst : NontriviallyNormedField ๐•œ] {E : Type*} [NormedAddCommGroup E] [NormedSpace ๐•œ E] {H : Type*} [TopologicalSpace H] : ModelWithCorners ๐•œ E H โ†’ {M : Type u_4} โ†’ [TopologicalSpace M] โ†’ [ChartedSpace H M] โ†’ M โ†’ Type (max (max u_4 u_1) u_1)

    Mathlib.Geometry.Manifold.DerivationBundle ยท lines 90โ€“91

    Community Agent The pipeline said more general; changed by Meta FAIR 2 (agent) โ€” owned by Jack McCarthy on 9 Nov 2026.

    Why close, not exact: Mathlib's PointDerivation is a derivation at x of the algebra of globally smooth scalar functions on the manifold, acting through evaluation at x, rather than of the algebra of germs at x, and it allows any nontrivially normed field. The convention difference is the function algebra: global smooth functions instead of germs. Its docstring says these derivations match the usual tangent space for finite-dimensional smooth real manifolds, but not in general.

    Details
    • Found by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: candidate 1 for this passage, medium confidence.
    • Re-checked by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC), challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack: it survived.
    • Record set tierA-b1b, exported 1 Nov 2026 by formal-companion d85385a.
    • Lean code: the declaration's type as Lean prints it, laid out as a header (the corpus keeps no hypothesis names), from the declaration corpus of universe u1 at commit 3dfb8e2.
    • Location key e64ad2ef42e8 ยท pair key c268885f939c.
  81. Definition ยท main statement ยท Tangent circles

    Partial

    Partial: Mathlib states a special case (a Prop-valued definition: it states the claim without proving it).

    Two distinct circles lying in the same plane are said to be tangent to each other if they meet at exactly one point.

    Show in article ยท Read it in context on Wikipedia

    EuclideanGeometry.Sphere.IsExtTangent special case

    def EuclideanGeometry.Sphere.IsExtTangent {V : Type*} {P : Type*} [NormedAddCommGroup V] [InnerProductSpace โ„ V] [MetricSpace P] [NormedAddTorsor V P] : EuclideanGeometry.Sphere P โ†’ EuclideanGeometry.Sphere P โ†’ Prop

    Mathlib.Geometry.Euclidean.Sphere.Tangent ยท lines 447โ€“448

    Why a special case: Mathlib has no single tangency relation for two spheres; it splits the notion into an external and an internal one, and this declaration covers only the external configuration.

    Details
    • Found by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: candidate 1 for this passage, medium confidence.
    • Re-checked by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC), challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack: it survived.
    • Record set tierA-b1b, exported 1 Nov 2026 by formal-companion d85385a.
    • Lean code: the declaration's type as Lean prints it, laid out as a header (the corpus keeps no hypothesis names), from the declaration corpus of universe u1 at commit 3dfb8e2.
    • Location key 326291a8eaf1 ยท pair key 17876b8b9c39.

    EuclideanGeometry.Sphere.IsIntTangent special case

    def EuclideanGeometry.Sphere.IsIntTangent {V : Type*} {P : Type*} [NormedAddCommGroup V] [InnerProductSpace โ„ V] [MetricSpace P] [NormedAddTorsor V P] : EuclideanGeometry.Sphere P โ†’ EuclideanGeometry.Sphere P โ†’ Prop

    Mathlib.Geometry.Euclidean.Sphere.Tangent ยท lines 458โ€“459

    Why a special case: Besides covering only the internal configuration, Mathlib's relation also admits the degenerate case of two equal spheres, which the passage rules out by asking the circles to be distinct.

    Details
    • Found by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: candidate 2 for this passage, medium confidence.
    • Re-checked by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC), challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack: it survived.
    • Record set tierA-b1b, exported 1 Nov 2026 by formal-companion d85385a.
    • Lean code: the declaration's type as Lean prints it, laid out as a header (the corpus keeps no hypothesis names), from the declaration corpus of universe u1 at commit 3dfb8e2.
    • Location key e8d233e922eb ยท pair key 9e537aaee62a.
  82. Theorem ยท main statement ยท Tangent circles

    Partial

    Partial: Mathlib states part of this (proved).

    If points in the plane are described using Cartesian coordinates, then two circles, with radii r1, r2 and centers (x1, y1) and (x2, y2) are tangent to each other whenever (x1 โˆ’ x2)2 + (y1 โˆ’ y2)2 = (r1 ยฑ r2)2.

    Show in article ยท Read it in context on Wikipedia

    EuclideanGeometry.Sphere.isExtTangent_iff_dist_center states part

    theorem EuclideanGeometry.Sphere.isExtTangent_iff_dist_center {V : Type*} {P : Type*} [NormedAddCommGroup V] [InnerProductSpace โ„ V] [MetricSpace P] [NormedAddTorsor V P] {sโ‚ sโ‚‚ : EuclideanGeometry.Sphere P} : sโ‚.IsExtTangent sโ‚‚ โ†” Dist.dist sโ‚.center sโ‚‚.center = sโ‚.radius + sโ‚‚.radius โˆง 0 โ‰ค sโ‚.radius โˆง 0 โ‰ค sโ‚‚.radius

    Mathlib.Geometry.Euclidean.Sphere.Tangent ยท lines 487โ€“509

    Why only part: Mathlib carries the extra conditions that both radii are nonnegative, which the passage's circles meet, and it says nothing about the minus sign of the passage's formula.

    Details
    • Found by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: candidate 1 for this passage, high confidence.
    • Re-checked by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC), challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack: it survived.
    • Record set tierA-b1b, exported 1 Nov 2026 by formal-companion d85385a.
    • Lean code: the declaration's type as Lean prints it, laid out as a header (the corpus keeps no hypothesis names), from the declaration corpus of universe u1 at commit 3dfb8e2.
    • Location key cd55346149d1 ยท pair key 9a4fa35b4b08.

    EuclideanGeometry.Sphere.isIntTangent_iff_dist_center states part

    theorem EuclideanGeometry.Sphere.isIntTangent_iff_dist_center {V : Type*} {P : Type*} [NormedAddCommGroup V] [InnerProductSpace โ„ V] [MetricSpace P] [NormedAddTorsor V P] [Nontrivial V] {sโ‚ sโ‚‚ : EuclideanGeometry.Sphere P} : sโ‚.IsIntTangent sโ‚‚ โ†” Dist.dist sโ‚.center sโ‚‚.center = sโ‚‚.radius - sโ‚.radius โˆง 0 โ‰ค sโ‚.radius โˆง 0 โ‰ค sโ‚‚.radius

    Mathlib.Geometry.Euclidean.Sphere.Tangent ยท lines 511โ€“545

    Why only part: Mathlib orients the pair so the first sphere sits inside the second and writes the difference in that order; it does not cover the plus sign of the passage's formula.

    Details
    • Found by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: candidate 2 for this passage, high confidence.
    • Re-checked by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC), challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack: it survived.
    • Record set tierA-b1b, exported 1 Nov 2026 by formal-companion d85385a.
    • Lean code: the declaration's type as Lean prints it, laid out as a header (the corpus keeps no hypothesis names), from the declaration corpus of universe u1 at commit 3dfb8e2.
    • Location key 331dbdfc0b65 ยท pair key f4e8c3abf5fb.
  83. Definition ยท main statement ยท Tangent circles

    Formalized

    Formalized: Mathlib states a more general result (a Prop-valued definition: it states the claim without proving it).

    The two circles are called externally tangent if the distance between their centres is equal to the sum of their radii, (x1 โˆ’ x2)2 + (y1 โˆ’ y2)2 = (r1 + r2)2.

    Show in article ยท Read it in context on Wikipedia

    EuclideanGeometry.Sphere.isExtTangent_iff_dist_center more general

    theorem EuclideanGeometry.Sphere.isExtTangent_iff_dist_center {V : Type*} {P : Type*} [NormedAddCommGroup V] [InnerProductSpace โ„ V] [MetricSpace P] [NormedAddTorsor V P] {sโ‚ sโ‚‚ : EuclideanGeometry.Sphere P} : sโ‚.IsExtTangent sโ‚‚ โ†” Dist.dist sโ‚.center sโ‚‚.center = sโ‚.radius + sโ‚‚.radius โˆง 0 โ‰ค sโ‚.radius โˆง 0 โ‰ค sโ‚‚.radius

    Mathlib.Geometry.Euclidean.Sphere.Tangent ยท lines 487โ€“509

    Why more general: Mathlib proves the characterisation for spheres in any real inner-product affine space, so the plane is one instance of it, and it adds nonnegativity of the two radii.

    Details
    • Found by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: candidate 1 for this passage, high confidence.
    • Re-checked by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC), challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack: it survived.
    • Record set tierA-b1b, exported 1 Nov 2026 by formal-companion d85385a.
    • Lean code: the declaration's type as Lean prints it, laid out as a header (the corpus keeps no hypothesis names), from the declaration corpus of universe u1 at commit 3dfb8e2.
    • Location key 8f309f98f360 ยท pair key 045c0d0f41dd.

    EuclideanGeometry.Sphere.IsExtTangent more general

    def EuclideanGeometry.Sphere.IsExtTangent {V : Type*} {P : Type*} [NormedAddCommGroup V] [InnerProductSpace โ„ V] [MetricSpace P] [NormedAddTorsor V P] : EuclideanGeometry.Sphere P โ†’ EuclideanGeometry.Sphere P โ†’ Prop

    Mathlib.Geometry.Euclidean.Sphere.Tangent ยท lines 447โ€“448

    Why more general: This is the object the passage names; Mathlib defines it for spheres in any dimension through the existence of a point of external contact, equivalent to the passage's distance condition.

    Details
    • Found by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: candidate 2 for this passage, medium confidence.
    • Re-checked by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC), challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack: it survived.
    • Record set tierA-b1b, exported 1 Nov 2026 by formal-companion d85385a.
    • Lean code: the declaration's type as Lean prints it, laid out as a header (the corpus keeps no hypothesis names), from the declaration corpus of universe u1 at commit 3dfb8e2.
    • Location key 9333d478874a ยท pair key 221ca7072338.
  84. Definition ยท main statement ยท Tangent circles

    Formalized

    Formalized: Mathlib states a more general result (a Prop-valued definition: it states the claim without proving it).

    (x1 โˆ’ x2)2 + (y1 โˆ’ y2)2 = (r1 + r2)2.
    or internally tangent if the distance between their centres is equal to the difference between their radii:[22] (x1 โˆ’ x2)2 + (y1 โˆ’ y2)2 = (r1 โˆ’ r2)2.

    Show in article ยท Read it in context on Wikipedia

    EuclideanGeometry.Sphere.isIntTangent_iff_dist_center more general

    theorem EuclideanGeometry.Sphere.isIntTangent_iff_dist_center {V : Type*} {P : Type*} [NormedAddCommGroup V] [InnerProductSpace โ„ V] [MetricSpace P] [NormedAddTorsor V P] [Nontrivial V] {sโ‚ sโ‚‚ : EuclideanGeometry.Sphere P} : sโ‚.IsIntTangent sโ‚‚ โ†” Dist.dist sโ‚.center sโ‚‚.center = sโ‚‚.radius - sโ‚.radius โˆง 0 โ‰ค sโ‚.radius โˆง 0 โ‰ค sโ‚‚.radius

    Mathlib.Geometry.Euclidean.Sphere.Tangent ยท lines 511โ€“545

    Why more general: Mathlib proves this for spheres in any real inner-product affine space, orients the pair so the first lies inside the second and writes the difference in that order; the passage squares the difference, so either order gives its equation.

    Details
    • Found by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: candidate 1 for this passage, high confidence.
    • Re-checked by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC), challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack: it survived.
    • Record set tierA-b1b, exported 1 Nov 2026 by formal-companion d85385a.
    • Lean code: the declaration's type as Lean prints it, laid out as a header (the corpus keeps no hypothesis names), from the declaration corpus of universe u1 at commit 3dfb8e2.
    • Location key 23671bc61204 ยท pair key 93917e053ac8.

    EuclideanGeometry.Sphere.IsIntTangent more general

    def EuclideanGeometry.Sphere.IsIntTangent {V : Type*} {P : Type*} [NormedAddCommGroup V] [InnerProductSpace โ„ V] [MetricSpace P] [NormedAddTorsor V P] : EuclideanGeometry.Sphere P โ†’ EuclideanGeometry.Sphere P โ†’ Prop

    Mathlib.Geometry.Euclidean.Sphere.Tangent ยท lines 458โ€“459

    Why more general: This is the object the passage names; Mathlib defines it in any dimension through the existence of a point of internal contact, equivalent to the passage's distance condition.

    Details
    • Found by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: candidate 2 for this passage, medium confidence.
    • Re-checked by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC), challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack: it survived.
    • Record set tierA-b1b, exported 1 Nov 2026 by formal-companion d85385a.
    • Lean code: the declaration's type as Lean prints it, laid out as a header (the corpus keeps no hypothesis names), from the declaration corpus of universe u1 at commit 3dfb8e2.
    • Location key 2af886f6afc0 ยท pair key a82ebf3a389a.
  85. Definition ยท main statement ยท Tangent plane to a surface

    Not formalized
    It is the best approximation of the surface by a plane at p, and can be obtained as the limiting position of the planes passing through 3 distinct points on the surface close to p as these points converge to p.

    Show in article ยท Read it in context on Wikipedia

    Searched 48 libraries โ€” not found. Which libraries, at which commits (pinned 2026-10-17).

    Details
    • Searched by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: the search receipt lists 5 queries and 2 candidates examined (receipt f889b026c052).
    • Re-checked by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC), challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack: upheld.
  86. Theorem ยท supporting ยท Tangent plane to a surface

    Not formalized
    (A technical detail is that the three points must approach p from at least two non-parallel directions.

    Show in article ยท Read it in context on Wikipedia

    Searched 48 libraries โ€” not found. Which libraries, at which commits (pinned 2026-10-17).

    Details
    • Searched by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: the search receipt lists 3 queries and 1 candidates examined (receipt 410b68391105).
    • Not re-checked: sampled out of challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack, in which Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) re-checked a sample on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC).
  87. Theorem ยท supporting ยท Tangent plane to a surface

    Not formalized
    More precisely, two of the three tangent vectors at p must be linearly independent.) Mathematically, if the surface is given by a function z = f(x, y), the equation of the tangent plane at point (x0, y0, z0) can be expressed as:

    Show in article ยท Read it in context on Wikipedia

    Searched 48 libraries โ€” not found. Which libraries, at which commits (pinned 2026-10-17).

    Details
    • Searched by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: the search receipt lists 3 queries and 2 candidates examined (receipt 0ffc4d646b32).
    • Re-checked by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC), challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack: upheld.
  88. Theorem ยท main statement ยท Tangent plane to a surface

    Not formalized
    More precisely, two of the three tangent vectors at p must be linearly independent.) Mathematically, if the surface is given by a function z = f(x, y), the equation of the tangent plane at point (x0, y0, z0) can be expressed as: z โˆ’ z0 = โˆ‚fโˆ‚x(x0, y0)(x โˆ’ x0) + โˆ‚fโˆ‚y(x0, y0)(y โˆ’ y0).

    Show in article ยท Read it in context on Wikipedia

    Searched 48 libraries โ€” not found. Which libraries, at which commits (pinned 2026-10-17).

    Details
    • Searched by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: the search receipt lists 3 queries and 2 candidates examined (receipt a9592be30305).
    • Re-checked by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC), challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack: upheld.
  89. Theorem ยท main statement ยท Higher-dimensional manifolds

    Formalized

    Formalized: TauCeti states a more general result (proved).

    More generally, there is a k-dimensional tangent space at each point of a k-dimensional manifold in the n-dimensional Euclidean space.

    Show in article ยท Read it in context on Wikipedia

    TauCeti.finrank_tangentSpace more general

    theorem TauCeti.finrank_tangentSpace {๐•œ : Type*} [NontriviallyNormedField ๐•œ] {E : Type*} [NormedAddCommGroup E] [NormedSpace ๐•œ E] {H : Type*} [TopologicalSpace H] {I : ModelWithCorners ๐•œ E H} {M : Type*} [TopologicalSpace M] [ChartedSpace H M] (x : M) : Module.finrank ๐•œ (TangentSpace I x) = Module.finrank ๐•œ E

    TauCeti.Geometry.Manifold.IsManifold.Basic ยท lines 34โ€“35

    Why more general: The declaration is stated over any nontrivially normed field and any normed model space, including infinite-dimensional ones and fields other than the reals, which are cases of real mathematical content outside the passage's setting, and it fixes no ambient Euclidean space.

    Details
    • Found by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: candidate 1 for this passage, high confidence.
    • Re-checked by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC), challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack: it survived.
    • Record set tierA-b1b, exported 1 Nov 2026 by formal-companion d85385a.
    • Lean code: the declaration's type as Lean prints it, laid out as a header (the corpus keeps no hypothesis names), from the declaration corpus of universe u1 at commit 83245ab.
    • Location key f6fe717fe726 ยท pair key f6541638a887.

    TangentSpace states part

    def TangentSpace {๐•œ : Type*} [inst : NontriviallyNormedField ๐•œ] {E : Type u} [NormedAddCommGroup E] [NormedSpace ๐•œ E] {H : Type*} [TopologicalSpace H] : ModelWithCorners ๐•œ E H โ†’ {M : Type*} โ†’ [TopologicalSpace M] โ†’ [ChartedSpace H M] โ†’ M โ†’ Type u

    Mathlib.Geometry.Manifold.IsManifold.Basic ยท lines 1033โ€“1042

    Community Agent The pipeline said more general; changed by Meta FAIR 2 (agent) โ€” owned by Jack McCarthy on 9 Nov 2026.

    Why only part: Mathlib's TangentSpace builds the tangent space at each point of a manifold modelled on a normed space (it is defined as the model space itself), which gives the passage's clause that a tangent space exists at each point. The definition does not itself state that this space has dimension k, and it treats abstract manifolds rather than ones sitting in Euclidean n-space.

    Details
    • Found by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: candidate 2 for this passage, medium confidence.
    • Re-checked by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC), challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack: it survived.
    • Record set tierA-b1b, exported 1 Nov 2026 by formal-companion d85385a.
    • Lean code: the declaration's type as Lean prints it, laid out as a header (the corpus keeps no hypothesis names), from the declaration corpus of universe u1 at commit 3dfb8e2.
    • Location key 2931aa530a17 ยท pair key ea42bd784f22.

    TauCeti.sphereTangentEquiv special case

    def TauCeti.sphereTangentEquiv {E : Type*} [NormedAddCommGroup E] [InnerProductSpace โ„ E] {n : โ„•} [Fact (Module.finrank โ„ E = n + 1)] (x : โ†‘(Metric.sphere 0 1)) : TangentSpace (modelWithCornersSelf โ„ (EuclideanSpace โ„ (Fin n))) x โ‰ƒโ‚—แตข[โ„] โ†ฅ(โ„ โˆ™ โ†‘x)แ—ฎ

    TauCeti.Geometry.Manifold.Riemannian.Sphere ยท lines 111โ€“116

    Why a special case: This is the sphere alone, not an arbitrary k-dimensional manifold in n-dimensional Euclidean space, and the codimension is fixed at one.

    Details
    • Found by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 31 Octโ€“1 Nov 2026 (UTC), locate run loc-tierA-b1b by jack: candidate 3 for this passage, medium confidence.
    • Re-checked by Claude Opus 5 (claude-opus-5) on 1 Nov 2026 (UTC), challenge run chal-tierA-b1 by jack: it survived.
    • Record set tierA-b1b, exported 1 Nov 2026 by formal-companion d85385a.
    • Lean code: the declaration's type as Lean prints it, laid out as a header (the corpus keeps no hypothesis names), from the declaration corpus of universe u1 at commit 83245ab.
    • Location key ff2e18a7da19 ยท pair key cc807665ff7d.

Data: view model (JSON) ยท Literature Links records (JSONL)